AIDWA Press Statement on the Suspension of Life Sentences of Two Convicts in the Bilkis Bano Case
The All India Democratic Women’s Association (AIDWA) expresses its deep disappointment and strong disapproval of the recent decision of the Supreme Court of India to grant bail to and suspend the sentences of Bipin Chand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, two of the convicts in the horrific gang rape of Bilkis Bano and the murder of 14 members of her family during the communal pogrom in Gujarat in 2002.
It is deeply shocking that individuals convicted of such heinous crimes should be granted bail on the grounds of prolonged incarceration, particularly when both convicts had already availed themselves of substantial periods of parole and furlough, spending more than 17 months outside prison. The decision, taken without hearing Bilkis Bano or even seeking her response, further compounds the trauma, fear and insecurity that she and her family have endured over the years.
Further, the reasons cited by the Court are vague and insufficiently explained. They neither establish the extent to which the alleged physical handicap of one of the convicts warrants such relief nor clarify why the other convict was belatedly included in the FIR. These grounds, as presented, do not adequately justify the suspension of their sentences. As reflected in Bilkis Bano’s own statement expressing her “pain, shock and disbelief”, the order represents a grave setback to justice, particularly when the Supreme Court itself had earlier quashed the Gujarat government's decision to grant remission to these convicts. It is pertinent to recall that AIDWA Vice-President Subhashini Ali was one of the petitioners who had challenged the remission granted to these convicts before the Supreme Court.
Moreover, the suspension of sentences in a case involving such exceptional brutality sends a deeply disturbing message and risks setting a dangerous precedent. It reinforces the perception that crimes against women, particularly Muslim women, can be committed with virtual impunity and without accountability. It also emboldens elements of the Sangh Parivar, whose open threats of violence and incitement against minorities, especially Muslims, further the Manuvadi Hindutva agenda with little apparent fear of consequences. At a time when violence against women continues unabated, the failure of the BJP government to ensure justice and accountability, particularly in cases involving the most brutal forms of sexual violence, is deeply condemnable.
AIDWA affirms that justice for Bilkis Bano is not merely an individual concern; it is a question of justice, dignity and security for all women and citizens. It stands firmly in solidarity with Bilkis Bano and her resolve to challenge this order.
Comrade Ashok Dhawale and Comrade Vijoo Krishnan have been re-elected as President and General Secretary of the All India Kisan Sabha (AIKS) at the 36th AIKS All India Conference in Nalgonda, Telangana. Comrade Pushpendra Tyagi has been elected as Finance Secretary. We extend revolutionary greetings to the newly elected leadership.
The Supreme Court verdict in the Bilkis Bano case is shocking, painful and unacceptable. CPI(M) stands in solidarity with Bilkis Bano. The party has taken the decision to extend all possible legal assistance to Bilkis Bano in her struggle for justice.
Student activists led by the SFI protested in front of Kolkata Police Headquarters in Lalbazar with books in hand, demanding the release of student movement leaders detained by the police while defending books at College Street.
The West Bengal Police brutally assaulted and arrested several SFI leaders and activists at the main gate of the University of Calcutta’s College Street campus earlier today, as students sought to organise their annual book stall commemorating the anniversary of the November Revolution. Female students were also subjected to physical harassment and assault. SFI West Bengal State Secretary Debanjan Dey, SFI State Secretariat member Shanu Chattopadhyay and SFI Central Executive Committee member Didhiti Roy were among those who were arrested.