Twitxy Saved

Dani Aparicio-Pérez

@dape595

Economist.
Valencia, España sites.google.com/view/daniel-ap… Joined June 2016
338 Following 148 Followers 305 Posts

Latest posts 5

Dani Aparicio-Pérez @dape595
Accurate.
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde Verified account @JesusFerna7026 Feb 13
I learned from a great Spanish economist many years ago that so many hate economists because they play in policy discussions the same role as the kid who told you in second grade that Santa Claus does not exist (well, since this was in Spain, the “Reyes Magos”).

You know it is true, but you hate him even more precisely because you know he is right. People listen to Jon Stewart (populist left) or Oren Cass (populist right) because they want to escape reality. Stewart and Cass are the discontents of adulthood, sellers of fantasies, partly out of intellectual immaturity, partly out of venal interests.

That said, we are not without blame in the profession. We often forget, for instance, that voters care about many issues beyond output growth. During the Brexit campaign, economists who argued for “remain” (which I defended) blissfully ignored issues of democracy, self-government, and regional balance within the UK, which were crucial to many voters. I see similar blindness in many other discussions in Europe right now, in particular in Spain. For instance, I have often voted for policies that did not maximize output growth but that I thought were important for other reasons.

At the end of the day, one should listen to experts to understand the trade-offs involved in different policy decisions, but being an expert does not provide deeper insight into how to adjudicate among competing claims. That ability comes from “prudence,” and “prudence” is not what gets you published in Econometrica.

As a profession, we would do well to remind ourselves that yes, Stewart and Cass are ignoramuses, but that we often lack “prudence” as well.
View quoted post on X