Twitxy Saved

EckSportsLab

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@deck1388

University of Illinois research lab where stats meet baseball history. Creators of peer-reviewed era-adjusted WAR. Featured in NYT. Babe Ruth is not the GOAT.
ecklab.github.io Joined May 2025
104 Following 518 Followers 630 Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

EckSportsLab Verified account @deck1388
The stats you use to compare baseball players across eras are not era-adjusted, even if they say they are.

WAR, OPS+, ERA+, etc do not account for changes to the talent pool and competition.

A 10-WAR season in 1925 is treated as identical to a 10-WAR season in 2025. It is not.
3 replies 0 reposts 13 likes 8.4K views View on X
EckSportsLab Verified account @deck1388
It's a good list overall! But someone is missing...as usual.

The omission is further validation for writing the following articles with it's subject buried

eracurveball.substack.com/p/be-nostalgic…
eracurveball.substack.com Be Nostalgic about Now: The Hall Of Fame Case for... First case study with 2026 era-adjusted stats!
All Aces Cards Verified account @AllAcesCards 20h
Every active MLB player who I think has at least a 50% chance of making the Hall of Fame, as of today:
Trout 100%
Scherzer 100%
Judge 100%
Betts 100%
Ohtani 99.9% (10 seasons)
Freeman 99%
Jansen 99%
Sale 99%
Altuve 95%
Kimbrel 90%
Goldy 90%
Harper 85%
Arenado 85%
Machado 85%
JRam 85%
Cole 80%
deGrom 75%
Lindor 75%
Skubal 50% (2 CYAs)
Aroldis 50% (DV)
Soto 50%
View quoted post on X
2 replies 0 reposts 31 likes 28K views View on X
EckSportsLab Verified account @deck1388
"Cole Hamels is ultimately a no"

That is a natural place to land when you are stuck in thinking that the pitching statistics from wins to WAR are remotely comparable across eras.

When you use stats that are era-adjusted-accounting for talent pool, competitive environment, and pitching usage-then Hamels's standing rises considerably.

For example, he ranks 35th all-time among pitchers in era-adjusted JAWS. He's ahead of Smoltz, Marichal, Bunning, Drysdale, Kid Nichols, Koufax, etc.

It may not be the sexiest case as judged awards. But I'm sure the 2008 Phillies appreciated having him en route to a winning the World Series, as he won the NLCS and WS MVPs!
Jim Miloch Verified account @podoffame 2d
I think Cole Hamels has a better case for the HOF than most (ultimately a no), but you can in fact vote for Felix and not Hamels. It all comes down to peak performance:

Felix: 1X Cy Young, 2X Cy Young Runner-Up, 2X ERA Title
Cole: 1X Top 5 Cy Young Finish

From 2009-2015, Felix was one of the best pitchers in baseball. Cole just was never in that conversation.
View quoted post on X
1 replies 0 reposts 12 likes 2.4K views View on X