HL succeeded in part thanks to a groundbreakingly democratic design that gave retail and small MMs a more level playing field. Louis makes a good point re read priority fees eroding this.
btw i think you may be arguing against a chatgpt X bot but for the sake of continuing the conversation...View quoted post on X
> Wintermute is and has always been a net positive for crypto
i broadly agree with this. wintermute is synonymous with functioning crypto markets. 'dont hate the player, hate the game'. if anyone blames them for their bags going down, maybe they should ask if their bags ever had intrinsic value in the first place.
> First of all it’s a read priority, which means that they pay for the access of incoming tx. They don’t get the ability to execute earlier than others
ok. so, the crux of the issue is not about picking others off on HL. the problem is this: they get to see when their orders will be filled, first - always, 50ms (60ms now) ahead of anyone else on hyperliquid, and then HEDGE before anyone else on other exchanges.
in doing so, they can size up to the point where they squeeze every last drop of juice out of smaller markets on HL, by consuming ALL of the profitable hedging liquidity on binance (et al).
the only reason they WOULDN'T do this is if they were being charitable and letting others take some pnl (or maxed out on position size). and wintermute is not a charity.
if there's only $100,000 of profitable hedging liquidity for UNI perps out to 50bps on binance+bybit+okx, then they can just quote that full amount / depth knowing they can consume ALL of the hedge liquidity, 100% of the time (simplifying a bit)
this means alts converge to having 1 market maker. which is structurally - and this is not debatable - bad. they could even quote wider than other MMs and still hedge ahead of them because they get to see their fills that much earlier. 60ms is an eternity in HFT. round trips between tokyo boxes is under 1ms, so that's 60+ round trips worth of network time. while everyone is listening to a dial tone.
so the actual question is, are we ok with having only a single market maker quoting markets on hyperliquid?
i would strongly argue no, we are not. it's not democratic, it's not sound microstructure. it's bad for hyperliquid, and it's bad for crypto.
> The 227M PnL is irrelevant because it was generated by a ton of alpha instead of just them having most of the priority slots
agree. also, for the sake of argument, they might have lost 228M on their hedges against these positions. they didn't, and the original number is probably not that far off, but you can't make any profitability claims based on their account history on a single venue. also wintermute is (mostly) not wearing naked HL positions w/o hedges.
> Why didn’t you mention on your other tweet that all crypto got nuked? You blame WM and HL for the 82% liq collapse but you don’t see you mentioning that nance is also down like 60%+ on that same period just like every other exchange lol
that's still a big difference, but causality here is difficult to prove. factually, i can tell you we can see binance's hedges hitting the binance tapes 60ms+ ahead of ours, and size-match it to their HL wallets fills. this is what is driving smaller MMs out.
we have recently cut our quoted symbols in half on HL from 120 to 60.
> It literally converts MMs trading edge in fees
no, that's not how it works. as mentioned, they could even quote *wider* than they otherwise would, because they have guaranteed hedge liquidity.
also, it's similar to how 0 fees doesn't mean 0 spreads. market makers do not just eat fees, they widen spreads according to costs.
there are shades of gray here, it's not binary, and i am open to a multiple equal-speed slot architecture with open, easy peering access for any slot winning wallet. that was my first recommended redesign in fact. but that may not be possible given the network/architecture.
> Abolishing the auction doesn’t change anything in fact it might actually make it worse. Do you know how much funds spend on infra every year? Take it away and now have the same exact thing happening but behind closed doors and with fewer participants
no. our all-in HL-related infra bill was around $15,000 last month, and i know for a fact we are within 1ms of wintermute's HL latency, absent read-priority.
wintermute spent $828,676.86 on read priority in the past 30d. this fact is available from hl core chain data.
$828,676.86 > $15,000. could argue the point on engineering, but there's not that much engineering required once everything is in place.
furthermore i doubt they reduced their infra costs with read priority, but you'd have to ask them
> The auction is better for the smaller MMs because they can’t afford the infra cost to race for ms, but they can afford to buy temporary priority
no. this was the stated intention, but i struggle to see how they didn't see the obvious outcome of the deepest pocketed player dominating the auction. which makes me think this was intended as a v0 that just hasn't been updated yet. so now it's time to update or simplify (abolish).
> I never personally worked in HFT/MM but Id argue that since it massively helps against adverse selection it also allows MMs to quote with much deeper liq at top of book and sometimes maybe even tighter spreads
the incentive could also be the opposite, as stated above. my observed behavior, as an HFT MM competing directly with them, staring at this stuff 90 hours per week, is that alt markets are and will continue to converge to having a single market maker because nobody else can quote profitably. if wintermute blows up, or decides to stop quoting, or their systems take a dump for 12 hours on a wednesday, those markets go quiet. bad.
> 1. WM is buying 76% of slots because they’re better than everyone else
> 2. They’re buying it so others don’t have access to it
> Sorry to say but in both cases it’s based af lmao
i more or less agree. they're just playing the game, and winning. i would again like to state unequivocally, wintermute is NOT the problem here! they're just playing the game and winning.
but if we're going to house all of finance the game cannot be designed in this way. it has serious risks, and it is not good enough. i've spoken to many smart people about this and they all agree. respectfully, the only one who disagrees is the one who's winning the game.
hyperliquid should stick to its day-1 values and be a democratic, open ecosystem that is NOT designed for the few. it should be designed to support the deepest liquidity, with the most participants, to serve a global market.
and under the current design, it's simply not so.