Twitxy Saved

George Harrell

@geharrell

Humanities teacher with @KeplerEducation
Executive Director of @BuchananForum
Twitter is my commonplace book
(Quotes are not endorsements)
Moscow, ID georgeharrell.substack.com Joined May 2015
931 Following 569 Followers 5K Posts

Latest posts 5

George Harrell @geharrell
Student question: “In previous talks, I'm remembering specifically the talk that you gave at ARC 2026, and you've echoed the same sentiment in past talks as well, that you have this invocation, perhaps a vocation maybe, of telling people to go to the church, go back to church and shed their secularized lifestyles and return to a proper religiosity. We right now in America and across the world live in an increasingly secular society. True religiosity has been on a downward trend for probably the past several hundred years ever since the enlightenment. Is there a kind of systematic solution that you can achieve to reinstate the power of religion, reinstate the power of church on a kind of mass grand scale? Or is that lost to us now?”

@PageauJonathan: “I don't think you want that. I don't think anybody wants that. I do believe that the only solution is personal ultimately; that the only solution is to become a saint.”
George Harrell @geharrell
"At a social and cultural level, especially in the public sphere, the challenge is much greater, and success is much less likely. No prophet or army of prophets can permanently dismantle the Ministry of Disenchantment. And this should be obvious to all Christians. Let’s face it: The concept of a 'disenchanted world' applies only to Western culture and, more specifically, to the world once known as Christendom. The enchantment that has been eclipsed by the Ministry, after all, is the one Christ brought to earth two thousand years ago, and that enchantment, though gradually globalized over two millennia, has never been complete, not even in long-vanished kingdoms or empires that forcibly baptized all of their subjects."
George Harrell @geharrell
“It’s a possibly somewhat startling fact about George Washington that when his administration came under intense criticism, in 1793, and an emerging permanent opposition formed, with political organizations that promoted candidates, wrote petitions, signed resolutions, and generally groused, Washington insisted that the very existence of such organizations was unconstitutional. He wanted them shut down by executive force. In some cases, he wanted petitioners and signers of resolutions prosecuted.”
William Hogeland @WilliamHogeland 4d
Also on "is it fascism?" (less obliquely): williamhogeland.substack.com/p/american-fas…
View quoted post on X
George Harrell @geharrell
I am a big fan of Eamon Duffy’s corrective work, but I was reflecting on how this frequently gets forgotten in the wake of Protestant iconoclasm:

“Far from denying or downplaying the visibility of the church, the Reformation was an effort to make the church visible. The Catholic church was certainly visible, but what was visible was the church’s power and wealth and social prominence. Yet the essence of the church – the communion of the saints – was hidden. If you walked into a sixteenth-century Catholic church, you’d see a priest performing the Mass but you wouldn’t see the laity sharing the Eucharistic meal; if you walked into a Protestant church, you’d see the saints eating bread and drinking wine, holy ones receiving the holy things, the table communion of saints made visible.”

Via @PLeithart
George Harrell @geharrell
This was a really great analysis of "the last documentary" here by @PageauJonathan -

"The film is a brilliant exploration of the limits of representation. Through its many layers of documentary filmmaking, acting, and manipulation, the film raises important questions about our ability to discern representation and reality, why we tell stories, and how symbolism can reveal truths that factual accuracy alone cannot capture."