Pinned post
Jill Lepore has a new piece in @NewYorker asking "Is A.I. Above the Law?" She quotes my recent article and takes a swing at its argument that general-purpose law is quite capable of handling new tech. (Her own word for my view is "mortifying," but I've heard worse!)
We disagree about the cure. Lepore sees the absence of new federal AI statutes as leaving agents in a lawless no man's land. But general law isn't nothing. Tort, contract, agency, fraud, and property law have absorbed the printing press, railroads, telephones, mass manufacturing, and the internet. And courts are already sorting AI agents into familiar categories (the Ninth Circuit's recent Amazon v. Perplexity decision, e.g., treats an agent as a user tool, not a legal actor).
Still, the history is rich, the Hugging Face episode is genuinely alarming, and she makes the case for new legislation about as well as it can be made. Read it and decide for yourself.
#AILaw
We disagree about the cure. Lepore sees the absence of new federal AI statutes as leaving agents in a lawless no man's land. But general law isn't nothing. Tort, contract, agency, fraud, and property law have absorbed the printing press, railroads, telephones, mass manufacturing, and the internet. And courts are already sorting AI agents into familiar categories (the Ninth Circuit's recent Amazon v. Perplexity decision, e.g., treats an agent as a user tool, not a legal actor).
Still, the history is rich, the Hugging Face episode is genuinely alarming, and she makes the case for new legislation about as well as it can be made. Read it and decide for yourself.
#AILaw
Congress has not passed a single federal law regulating A.I. in any meaningful way. Meanwhile, by 2025, there was more bot traffic on the internet than human traffic—and some futurists believe Androids could outnumber humans in the real world, too.View quoted post on X
newyorker.com/magazine/2026/…