$CARDS sellers have unlimited token supply and have been net selling ~300k daily
It's actually insane how much supply the sellers have, like how much are their unlocks for this sort of relentless selling
Coupled with dropping daily revenues and it is tough to be bullish
It's actually insane how much supply the sellers have, like how much are their unlocks for this sort of relentless selling
Coupled with dropping daily revenues and it is tough to be bullish
solana:CARDSccUMFKoPRZxt5vt3ksUbxEFEcnZ3H2pd3dKxYjp: Record Month, Falling ChartView quoted post on X
@Collector_Crypt just had the biggest month in its history, and solana:CARDSccUMFKoPRZxt5vt3ksUbxEFEcnZ3H2pd3dKxYjp is down 57% from the top. Both of those things are true at the same time, and that gap is what this piece is about. So let's start with the part that hurts.
The price action
solana:CARDSccUMFKoPRZxt5vt3ksUbxEFEcnZ3H2pd3dKxYjp sits around $0.164 tonight, down 24% on the week and 44% on the month. The ATH was $0.38 in late October. Market cap went from about $339M at the peak to $146M, and FDV is $323M.
The two biggest volume days this month were listing days. That's a chart that looks like a business in trouble. The business itself tells a very different story.
The business
October was the best month the business has ever had. On Oct 20 CC posted its biggest day yet: $24.3M in gross revenue in 24 hours and 123,425 packs opened.
October ended as a record $216M of packs, its best month ever. Q3 brought 18,376 first time Solana players, double Q2's 8,748.
November is cooling though. The last 7 days did $1.58M of revenue, about half the 30 day pace, and the daily line swings hard, $338k on Nov 13 and $47.7k on Nov 14.
Still, nothing here explains a 57% drawdown on its own. So why is the token bleeding?
Why the token is bleeding
I see three reasons.
1. The buyback is tiny
In Q3 the buyback bot spent $567k on solana:CARDSccUMFKoPRZxt5vt3ksUbxEFEcnZ3H2pd3dKxYjp. That's 2.2% of $25.4M gross profit.
The whole quarter of buying is less than a tenth of one day's volume right now ($7.9M).
Most of the profit goes back into the machines instead: $11.6M on new cards and $8.2M replacing the ones players kept.
2. Supply keeps coming
891M tokens circulate out of ~1.97B.
Team, advisor and seed wallets still have nine unlock steps and 347M tokens left. The next one is Nov 29.
If it matches the Oct 29 step (39.4M), that's about $6.5M of new supply at today's price.
3. The market
SOL went from ~$90 to ~$71.5 in a week. Hard to pump a consumer token into that.
And then there's the one everyone was betting on: listings.
Do listings move the price?
They did, for about a day each. Coinbase put solana:CARDSccUMFKoPRZxt5vt3ksUbxEFEcnZ3H2pd3dKxYjp on its roadmap on Nov 3 and CC called it "a big milestone for Collector Crypt, with so much still ahead". Price closed that day up ~17%.
Upbit opened KRW, BTC and USDT pairs on Nov 5 and it wicked to $0.30. Coinbase went live Nov 6, Bithumb Nov 10, and it has trended lower since. From the Upbit wick it's down ~46%. Textbook sell the news.
Every listing gave the token a day of attention, and every time the price gave it back. Hype fades, but the business underneath it doesn't. So once you strip the listings out, the real question is what the token is worth on the numbers alone.
My take
On the numbers alone, it looks cheap. At $146M market cap, solana:CARDSccUMFKoPRZxt5vt3ksUbxEFEcnZ3H2pd3dKxYjp trades at about 1.4x Q3 gross profit annualised, ~3.2x on FDV. That's a low multiple for a business that did $24.3M of gross revenue in a single day last month. Not financial advice.
So why isn't the market paying more? Part of it has nothing to do with CC. SOL dropped from ~$90 to ~$71.5 in a week, and when the whole market is bleeding, nobody is hunting for undervalued consumer tokens.
Money is leaving alts, not rotating into them. Even CT streamers are ripping packs instead of trading "due to market conditions", which says a lot. People still want the thrill, they just don't want the bag.
Which leaves one question for you.
Would you rather hold the token or just rip the packs?