Twitxy Saved

Inside Politics

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@insidepols

Analysis of and commentary on South African politics. Edited by: @GvanOnselen
South Africa inside-politics.org Joined February 2012
1 Following 4.4K Followers 740 Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Inside Politics Verified account @insidepols
Hello all, welcome to the home of SA election data. I am going to treat this account like a live blog almost, talking about the data I have, how things are being developed and of course the outcomes. If you are interested in that kind of stuff, I would love to talk to you about it. Insights, thoughts, requests all welcome. All of the final data will appear on my blog - inside-politics.org - it already has a ton of stuff up on it, and I am always growing and developing it. So, if this kind of thing appeals to you, welcome!
inside-politics.org inside politics Analysis of and commentary on South African politics.
2 replies 0 reposts 20 likes 13K views View on X
Inside Politics Verified account @insidepols
How did the ANC's by-election track hold up against its election result?
1/2
I had a look at the ANC's by-election track (below), to see how it lined up with the final LGE result. I was pleasantly surprised. The track finished with the ANC on 34.86% (the last by-elections were held on 24 June, 133 days before the 4 November LGE). The ANC got 30.63% on the ward ballot, so the track was 4.23pts out. The trend was clearly right too, ANC headed downwards.
The track uses a 12 month moving average (12 MA). So every dot represents the average ANC vote share across the most recent 12 months in which qualifying by-elections took place, including the month represented by that dot.
This is by design (a personal decision based on a range of factors that make the most sense), and means the track is not at all sensitive to immediate change but extremely good at general trends. That was the pay-off, and so, given those inherent limitations, you really cannot ask more of the track. It absolutely delivered (another reason for you guys to subscribe to it, ahead of 2029!)
I did, as a matter of interest, reduce the MA to 6, to see what it did to the track, and while it was closer in 2026 (32.08%), it became far further out in other years. So I maintain that 12 MA is the right call. If by-election become as volatile as the metros did in this election, I might move it to something lower.
Inside Politics Verified account @insidepols
The ANC, MK and the EFF: Mashaba’s new patronage government

As ASA continues to discuss potentially working together with the ANC, MK and EFF to form a series of coalition governments, it is worth looking at ASA’s other coalition “non-negotiable”, described many times by interim president Herman Mashaba, on the campaign trail.
This was the precondition that municipal services must reach all communities, irrespective of wealth, location or political allegiance.Mashaba said, “If a party feels that they only want to provide services to their voters and constituencies, please then don’t talk to us, because there is going to be a fight somewhere along the line.”
Once again, however, this sits in stark contrast to his historical attitude towards the ANC - under Zuma and after him – and the EFF.
In 2021, Mashaba condemned “rising unemployment and poverty whilst ANC cadres enrich themselves,” a common theme in his analysis, which revolved around the idea that, “the ANC have used South Africa’s democracy to enrich themselves and their cronies.”
This attitude, he argued, seeped all the way down to municipal level. As far back as 2017, he complained, “It is unfortunate that the ANC will use Council’s time and taxpayer’s money in their mission to further enriching themselves.”
Talking about the Alexandra Renewal Project in 2019 he said, “There can be no question that the R16 billion set aside by National and Provincial Government for the ARP has been looted and used by the ANC as a tool for self-enrichment.”
This was a common pattern, he argued, Johannesburg's Accelerated Service Delivery programme, he said “was obviously a program insidiously designed to enrich those in the ANC’s patronage network and act as a smokescreen for ‘service delivery.’”
The ANC, he said, “was there to serve a political party first and a community second”
That was obviously, particularly true of Zuma, whom Mashaba said, “abused his office for the benefit of himself, his son and the Guptas”. The EFF too, of which he has said, “The party’s leadership are Gucci people” – although it must be said, Mashaba’s criticism of the EFF is muted, perhaps a consequence of the party cleverly dubbing him, “The EFF’s mayor”.
But the VBS-EFF scandal was so big, even Mashaba could not avoid no comment. An ASA statement said, “There's no way we can fold our arms as if nothing is happening while people are enriching themselves”
And so it goes. Once again, a public record littered with statement after statement, describing the Zuma, Malema and the ANC as self-enriching, who use government access to service their own interests, at the expense of service delivery and the people. Who put “a community second”.
Despite this, Mashaba would have us believe these parties are capable of passing his “non-negotiable” test, as they are on corruption, and are now both fully reformed and fully committed to service delivery for all.
It is a difficult sell.
5 replies 23 reposts 54 likes 11K views View on X
Inside Politics Verified account @insidepols
The ANC, MK and EFF: Mashaba's anti-poor trifecta

Should a coalition be formed between ASA, ANC, MK and EFF, ostensibly, as Herman Mashaba puts it, to be pro-poor, it is helpful to set out Mashaba's historical views on poverty, and who he believes has been responsible for it, to date.
"Why do they actually hate poor people..." Mashaba asked of Zuma's ANC in 2016. It is a question he has not yet found an answer to.
His explanation back then was, "They [Zuma's ANC] think poor people's issues can be addressed by food parcels and T-shirts instead of actually giving them their pride and really create employment opportunities for them, provide good education for them."
Speaking about homeless people in Sophiatown, Mashaba said back then that ANC wanted to "turn black people into public slaves and make them inhuman”
He asked the question, “I don't know why the ANC is depriving our people to actually get that first step into employment and climb up the ladder.”
In 2016, Mashaba said of the ANC in Johannesburg specifically, while Zuma was still president: “Their conduct is anti-poor, illegal and does not have the best interests of those who have been ignored by ANC for years at heart."
But, even after Zuma had gone, Mashaba continued his belief that the ANC was the primary anti-poor force in SA, not by accident, but the consequence of a clear and blatant anti-poor agenda.
When it came to education, Mashaba said of the ANC in 2021, “it’s clear they want to keep black people poor" - a view he reiterated in 2023: “And it's not a mistake; it's a plan by the ANC government to keep black people poor."
He said the ANC did this to control them: "I have always said the ANC wants to keep black people uneducated so that they can control them."
He has gone as far as to say of Ramaphosa's administration, “The high unemployment, inequality, the murder rate and lawlessness is not a mistake, it’s an engineered programme by the ANC government.”
It is a view Mashaba has extended to the EFF, of which he said in 2024, “The hatred of EFF for poor people is on steroids.”
It is odd set of views, as with his previous statements on corruption, especially given that Mashaba's election campaign position was: "If anyone wants to talk to us they must understand that us, as ActionSA, we want to run a pro-poor government.” He said, “Anyone who wants to talk to us must understand that we want to run a pro-poor government, [must] commit to serve all communities, and that social justice is a non-negotiable.”
And, it is no less odd, as with Mashaba's previous statements on corruption, that he should now seek to bring these particular parties together - which he believes have an overt agenda to neglect and dehu
manise poor people - when his undertaking to voters was precisely the opposite.