Twitxy Saved

Jordan Hall

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@jgreenhall

North Carolina, USA youtube.com/channel/UCMzT-… Joined March 2008
468 Following 18K Followers 9.7K Posts

Latest posts 5

Jordan Hall Verified account @jgreenhall
I was always curious why Hijabs fanboys thought a lack of intelligence on his part was an argument against the Trinity.
Jonathan Pageau Verified account @PageauJonathan 2d
What you mean is Mohamed Hijab deceives Jordan Peterson by inviting him to discuss the role of Jesus in Islam and then proceeds to attack Christianity in a mosque in front of 50 Muslim men who did not hesitate to then intimidate me simply because I questioned Hijab’s character. Bullies gonna bully. That does not make them convincing.
View quoted post on X
3 replies 5 reposts 127 likes 3.9K views View on X
Jordan Hall Verified account @jgreenhall
What an interesting reveal.

Let’s assume for the moment that this is true (and there is no real reason to believe it is).

The power move is to sit back and wait. If Iran does nothing, there is no unpopular war and red wins the midterms.

If Iran launches an attack on Paris or London?? Suddenly the admin is *handed* a popular war and red destroys the midterms.

Nothing is more unpopular than an unpopular war - nothing is more popular than a popular war.

If this video is truthful, it is saying that the Trump admin made the stupidest choice - just from the point of power politics.

Makes me wonder what the OP is.
Mor Edge Insight Verified account @MorEdge_Insight Nov 6
Wow. Senator John Kennedy.

How is this not everywhere.
Seriously. This is insane. Listen to what he’s actually saying.

View quoted post on X
41 replies 7 reposts 97 likes 9.2K views View on X
Jordan Hall Verified account @jgreenhall
It has come to my attention that many people are unclear on the concept of "a generation". They don't know what the generations are or why such a concept has meaning. I've considered this idea deeply for a few decades and thought I'd quickly drop my sense of the matter. This is a very quick writeup-so don't expect much. A human generation is not defined by chronology and is not an arbitrary thing drawn up by historians, demographers or anthropologists. The best way to understand it is by means of the concept of the "zeitgeist" - or the "sprit of the time." The idea is that a zeitgeist is a real thing (as real as a culture, a language or a sports team); that people who live in a particular zeitgeist are meaningfully formed by it; and that zeitgeists change over time, often discontinuously.

So, for example, you are not a boomer if you were born in 1946. You are a boomer because your childhood was defined by the post-War zeitgeist and not, for example, by the post Kennedy zeitgeist. Literally, there was an actual change in the nature of reality that occurred somewhere in the mid 1940's that made life after that point different in the same way that a mass shift from everyone speaking French to everyone speaking English would make life different (kids brought up in the latter era would speak English as their mothers tongue). And then, there was an actual change in reality that occured around the JFK assassination that led to what is effectively a "different world". Those who were infants in 1963 or born thereafter, were formed by that different world. And this makes a difference.
The zeitgeist changes in a variety of ways. We have minor (but real and significant) changes like the shift between 2006 and 2008 or 2023 and 2024, but the ones that matter are the major ones that come about once every . . . generation. WWII (probably pearl harbor). JFK. The Challenger event. 9/11. Covid. If you lived meaningfully before such an event you remember that something subtle but deeply real and important just changed at that time. You felt that you had woken up in a new world. That is because you did.

This then defines our most recent generations. You are a boomer if you were formed as a child by the post-WWII zeitgeist and remember the JFK portal. GenX was formed by the post-JFK world and remembers Challenger. Millenials were formed by the post Challenger world and remembers 9/11. And so on.
Notice that this theory easily takes into account that top down forces are real but not evenly distributed. Just like language, if you were born in Slovakia and moved to Ohio when you were eight, you'll have a different relationship with english than the locals. Yep. And still you are immersed in english in a way that is real and important. Same with the zeitgeist. The rain falls on everyone - differently. Now there is a deeper theory that tries to diagnose the particularity of each zeitgeist and the effects it has on people as a consequence of their developmental moment. Once again, we can say that the developmental stage of childhood is both general and particular. If you learn a language from infancy you will have a different experience of it than someone who learned it in adulthood - and this will be the same for every child. At the same time, every will have a different experience of the language they learned. Again, this is not a really difficult concept and as you can tell with my examples is common along a number of kinds of things, not just generations/zeitgeists. So if you were a child of the 1980's you had a different developmental relationship with that zeitgeist than someone who was in their 30's. The vibes of the 80's spirit would layer onto you differently. Not least because you had no previous layers to interpret and integrate them. So we have roughly two core drivers: the actual zeitgeist of a given moment and its movement over time; the differential developmental moments of people as they encounter these zeitgeists. Together, these build to a generational signature that has reality and real force in the larger cultural field.
14 replies 11 reposts 122 likes 4.1K views View on X
Jordan Hall Verified account @jgreenhall
Jordan Hall Verified account @jgreenhall Nov 1
Greetings young Sith, let’s have a chat.

Your essay is insightful and, at its core, substantially correct. I accept your reading of the Boomer generation and the mythology of Star Wars. The aesthetics, the simplistic moral universe, the endless recasting of every political disagreement into a struggle between liberators and Nazis, the treatment of Alderaan as a rubber stamp reading VILLAIN, the discovery that the hippies eventually became the Jedi Council, and the extraordinary hypocrisy of a generation that overthrew its fathers and now regards succession as an existential threat.

All of it. The frame is good. It is thick enough to be genuinely useful, even as it exposes the remarkable thinness, and frankly the stupidity, of the worldview it describes.

But something important is missing.

An entire generation, in fact.

And the absence of Generation X from your account reveals a larger story. One that makes sense of the Boomer mythology, explains why it took the form that it did, and introduces a rather serious problem with your proposed solution.
View quoted post on X