Twitxy Saved

Joris Kuipers

@jkuipers

CTO & hands-on architect @triforkams. 40 over 40. Bluesky @joris.kuipe.rs
Amstelveen, Netherlands Joined January 2008
518 Following 1.3K Followers 3.9K Posts

Latest posts 5

Joris Kuipers @jkuipers
"As a social democrat, I attach a great deal of value to solidarity. But you also have obligations. You can't spend all your money on booze and women and then ask for help."
— Dutch Finance Minister and Eurogroup President Jeroen Dijsselbloem on Greece in 2017…
Peter Girnus 🦅 Verified account @gothburz Oct 9
I’m a senior official at Agence France Trésor. We manage the French Republic’s debt.

Next year I’ll borrow €340 billion from people who aren’t totally sure France is going to pay them back. That’s a record. This year it was €310 billion, also a record. Records are kind of our thing.

Here’s the part nobody in Brussels will say out loud. I don’t have to convince investors France is safe. I just have to convince them Europe can’t afford to find out.

Let me walk you through it.

France last balanced a budget in 1973. Giscard was finance minister. We still had the franc. Most of the people voting in 2027 weren’t born yet. We’ve run a deficit every year since, 52 in a row, which is honestly the most consistent thing about French politics. Our debt is 119% of GDP this year and 121.7% next year, and that’s the optimistic version, the one with the cuts in it.

The cuts. The government announced a €54 billion “effort” for 2027. Effort is a beautiful word. Effort means you tried. Even if every euro of it happens, the debt keeps growing. It just grows a bit slower, which in my office counts as a victory parade. The budget has to clear parliament by the end of December, and parliament has no majority, so the deputies are fighting over it like it’s the last baguette at 7pm.

Meanwhile, interest. This year the state pays about €65 billion just to service what it already owes. Next year it’s €74 billion. Pretty soon the biggest line in the French budget won’t be schools or soldiers. It’ll be the people we borrowed from to pay for the schools and the soldiers.

Then there’s the spread. That’s the extra we pay to borrow because we’re France and they’re Germany. In February it was 55 basis points. On October 1 it hit about 140, the widest since 2011 and 2012, back when Greece was on the evening news every night. The 10-year yield touched about 4.2%, a level we last saw in 2008. I remember 2008. I had hair.

57% of our debt is held by foreigners. I love foreigners. Foreigners can’t vote. They can, however, sell. Every morning I check the screen to see whether they’ve sold, the way other men check the weather.

Now, here’s what I’d never say on a call.

There’s a facility at the European Central Bank called the Transmission Protection Instrument. If a country’s bond market gets “disorderly,” the ECB can step in and buy. To qualify, you’re supposed to comply with the EU’s fiscal rules. France is in an excessive deficit procedure, which is Brussels for “you’re in detention.” Our lawyers’ position is that being in detention counts as attending school. So far nobody’s tested it. Nobody wants to.

Because if France goes, the euro goes. If the euro goes, the EU goes. Everybody in Frankfurt knows it, and everybody in Frankfurt knows we know it. That’s our collateral. Germany has a debt brake. We have a hostage. And Europe can’t afford to call our bluff, which is why I sleep pretty well, considering.

The biggest single thing in our budget is pensions, so naturally nobody touches them. The 2023 reform raised the retirement age to 64. Then it got suspended until after the election. On October 6, the candidate leading the polls promised to cut the debt ratio in half by trimming 3% of GDP. Yields dipped a little. She also still wants to lower the retirement age. People are living longer every year, and every year we promise to pay them for longer, starting sooner. It’s the most generous math in Europe.

And then there’s the part that keeps me up at night. Hold on, I said I sleep well. Let’s say it keeps me up some nights.

In September I flew to London to pitch a new long bond. Nice hotel, good coffee, 40 fund managers. My slide had Marianne on it. Four tables down, the treasurer of an American cloud company was pitching a bond to build data centres. His slide had a GPU on it.

Guess whose table had the line.

He offered them a piece of the future. I offered them a piece of 1973. Analysts later said about half the jump in our 10-year yield since August had nothing to do with France: inflation from the war, plus cloud companies sucking up the world’s capital to build their machines. So half my spread is about us. The other half is about him. He’s not even mad at me. He doesn’t know I exist. Some of his customers are French ministries.

Let me tell you about Madame Garnier.

She’s 76 and lives in Villeurbanne, outside Lyon. She taught primary school for 38 years. She has a cat named Robespierre, which she thinks is hilarious, and she’s right.

Madame Garnier owns my bonds. She doesn’t know it. Her savings sit in an assurance-vie, like half of France, and the fonds euros inside it is stuffed with OATs. So she’s my creditor. She’s also my plan.

Here’s how it works. If we can’t cut, and we can’t, there’s an old, quiet way out. It doesn’t need 289 votes in the Assemblée. It just needs prices to go up a little faster than everyone’s promised. Her pension gets indexed in January. Inflation doesn’t wait for January. Her bonds pay a fixed rate. Inflation doesn’t care. Every year it runs a bit hot, the Republic’s debt shrinks a little in real terms, and so does Madame Garnier.

She’ll never see it in a headline. She’ll see it at the boulangerie, and she’ll blame the baker.

Last month her granddaughter, Inès, 19, was out in the street with the other students protesting the cuts. She’s furious that her university budget got trimmed. She’s right to be. She’s also the one who’ll be paying the €74 billion, and the €91 billion after that, for the next 40 years. She’s protesting the wrong generation. Her grandmother made her a sign.

The sign said L’avenir n’est pas à vendre. The future isn’t for sale.

Inès, sweetheart, I sold it in March. Syndicated deal. 4 times oversubscribed.

I meet my team every Monday. They know the auction calendar by heart. They know which banks will bid and which ones need a phone call. They celebrate when a deal is oversubscribed, and they should. They’re brilliant. They do impossible work, beautifully. I’m incredibly proud of them.

Together we’ve built something remarkable: a country that can never go bankrupt, because everyone’s too afraid of what happens if it does.

Somebody always pays. The whole trick is making sure they’re too old to notice or too young to vote.

Madame Garnier is 76. Inès is 19.

Between them, they’ve got it covered.
View quoted post on X