Twitxy Saved

Joel Fish

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@joelwatsonfish

Mathematics Professor. Husband. Father. Irritating. Podcast host (Academia on the Line). Polyfolder and feral curve tamer.
Boston academiaontheline.com Joined July 2012
481 Following 1.9K Followers 5.4K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Joel Fish Verified account @joelwatsonfish
So... I've started a podcast with my friend (and Brown University Math Professor) Carina Curto. It's called "Academia on the Line".

Our first episode is now available! Many thanks to our guests: Professors Melanie Matchett Wood and Daniel Litt (@littmath). We discuss OpenAI's result on the Erdős Unit Distance Problem and what AI may mean for mathematical research.

Find us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Podcasts, etc.

x.com/AcademiaOTL/st…
Academia on the Line is now live.

Our inaugural episode features Professors Melanie Matchett Wood and Daniel Litt (@littmath) discussing OpenAI's result on the Erdős Unit Distance Problem and what AI may mean for mathematical research.

academiaontheline.com
View quoted post on X
5 replies 6 reposts 53 likes 26K views View on X
Joel Fish Verified account @joelwatsonfish
I think OAI and ANT are each like the perfect mathematician: incredibly intelligent (but mostly at math), while being unable survive financially without perpetual donations from society’s surpluses. Not to mention working very hard to pass as not-sociopathic.
Joel Fish Verified account @joelwatsonfish
And when Lean code is LLM generated and is a million lines long, how much trust should we have?
Alex Kontorovich Verified account @AlexKontorovich 1d
No, you just have to know a little bit about what you're doing. Here's a simpler instance.

The first example tries to prove that 2 - 3 = -1; this is true in the integers, and so that's how the question is interpreted (to be helpful to the user), and `by simp` solves the goal.

The second example tries to prove that 2 - 3 = 0; this is true in the natural numbers (because of "total functions"), and so that's how the question is interpreted (to be helpful to the user), and `by simp` solves the goal.

So no, you shouldn't just blindly "trust the Lean"; you should learn what you're doing.

And *then* you can trust the Lean. :)
View quoted post on X
3 replies 0 reposts 21 likes 1.1K views View on X