Twitxy Saved

jon hagedorn, md

@jonhagedornmd

husband. father. physician. runner.
life and running.
Joined October 2016
2K Following 5.4K Followers 9.8K Posts

Latest posts 5

jon hagedorn, md @jonhagedornmd
More heat training evidence. Similar impact on VO2max as the study I shared earlier.
Daniel Tawfik Verified account @dantawfik 7h
Elite cyclists trained for five weeks wearing wool layers, a down jacket, and a rain shell indoors. Their blood volume rose, their VO2max rose, and 15 minute all-out power rose by 7 to 10%. Their muscles didn't change at all.

A 2023 study in the Journal of Applied Physiology tested whether heat training improves performance in elite athletes, and whether women respond the same way men do.

Most heat research has been done in men. Women are known to take longer to acclimatize to heat (the body's adjustment to hot conditions). So it wasn't clear if the benefits would transfer.

The researchers, led by Carsten Lundby and Bent Rønnestad at Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences, recruited 47 elite cyclists: 20 women (average VO2max 58.2 mL/min/kg) and 27 men (average 76.4). VO2max is the maximum rate your body can use oxygen, a standard measure of aerobic fitness.

They were randomized into a control group or a heat group. Both did five 50 minute sessions per week for five weeks, at a moderate effort, in a room at about 19.5°C. The only difference was clothing. The heat group wore insulating layers that trap body heat, which this team has previously shown raises core temperature about as much as exercising in a hot environment.

The sessions replaced part of normal training, so total training volume didn't increase. Everyone took 100 mg of iron daily. Compliance was 100%.

Key findings:

• Hemoglobin mass (total hemoglobin in the body, the oxygen-carrying protein in red blood cells) rose 4.0% in women (650 to 675 g) and 3.5% in men (1,008 to 1,041 g). After adjusting for baseline, the heat group gained 13.5 g more than controls.
• Blood volume was 262 mL higher and plasma volume (the liquid part of blood) was 141 mL higher in the heat group.
• VO2max rose by about 2.4 mL/min/kg more than in controls.
• Power at the lactate threshold (the intensity where lactate starts to accumulate quickly in the blood) rose by 7.7 W compared to controls.
• Mean power during a 15 minute all-out test was 15 W higher. That's about 10.2% in women and 7% in men.
• Muscle citrate synthase activity (a marker of mitochondrial content), fiber type, and capillary density were unchanged.
• Women and men responded similarly. The one exception was power at lactate threshold, where men gained more.

Here is how the pieces likely fit together.

First, heat stress expands plasma volume within days. That is the well-known early response, and it helps with cooling and cardiac filling.

Second, over several weeks, red blood cell production appears to follow. Total hemoglobin goes up, which raises the blood's capacity to carry oxygen.

Third, more oxygen delivery per heartbeat raises VO2max and the power sustainable at a given effort. The gains in VO2max, lactate threshold power, and 15 minute power each correlated with the increase in hemoglobin mass (r = 0.44 to 0.50).

The muscle data point the same way. If heat training had built more mitochondria or capillaries, those markers should have moved. They didn't. The benefit looks like a central, blood-based change rather than a local muscle adaptation.

The mechanism behind the hemoglobin rise is not settled. The authors point to HIF (hypoxia-inducible factor, a cellular oxygen-sensing switch) and erythropoietin (EPO, the hormone that drives red blood cell production) as candidates. But EPO usually shrinks plasma volume, the opposite of what heat does, and the heat evidence for EPO is inconsistent. They call several of these explanations speculative.

Limitations worth knowing:

• Effort was set by perceived exertion, so a given session may not have produced the same heat stress in every athlete, especially between sexes. Actual heat load and acclimatization weren't measured.
• The menstrual cycle wasn't controlled in women, and female hormones affect blood volume.
• The groups differed at baseline in a few traits, including age and VO2max in some subgroups.
• Correlation between hemoglobin and performance doesn't prove hemoglobin caused the gains.
• Everyone supplemented iron. Results without it could differ.
• These were elite cyclists tested over five weeks. It tells us nothing about recreational athletes, other sports, or long-term effects.

The authors also note effects in elite athletes are likely marginal, and earlier smaller studies from the same group found no VO2max change. Larger samples may be why this one detected it.

What this means if you train for longevity:

VO2max is one of the strongest predictors of mortality we have. Large cohort studies consistently show that people with higher cardiorespiratory fitness live longer, and the biggest drop in risk is between the lowest and middle fitness groups. This study shows VO2max can be raised through oxygen delivery, not only through muscle adaptation. That is a second lever. It's an inference from this work, though. Nobody tested heat training for health outcomes here.

Several cautions apply:

• These were young, elite athletes with an average age of roughly 19 to 28. Older adults handle heat differently. Heat strain on the heart, dehydration, and blood pressure shifts matter more with age and with cardiovascular risk. Talk to a physician before overdressing for workouts if you have any heart or blood pressure issues.
• The heat was added to training, not used instead of it. Heat doesn't replace the aerobic base work and higher intensity intervals that build VO2max in the first place.
• Higher hemoglobin is not a longevity goal by itself. The target is oxygen delivery and fitness, and the gain here was a modest 3.5 to 4%.
• Sauna and hot baths weren't tested. They produce heat stress without exercise, and this study can't say whether they would raise hemoglobin or VO2max the same way.

The practical takeaway is narrow. If your aerobic training is already well built and you've plateaued, heat is a plausible extra stimulus. For most people, the larger returns still come from regular zone 2 work, some high intensity intervals, and showing up consistently for decades.

The broader point is that fitness doesn't only live in the muscle. Blood volume and hemoglobin are trainable, and heat is one way to push them. Whether that translates into a longer healthspan is the open question.
View quoted post on X
jon hagedorn, md @jonhagedornmd
The next thing we will be hearing about creatine is that it makes us look 10 years younger.
Sex offender @joshdavisx 21h
@jonhagedornmd After skimming that study about creatine and taking it myself all it really does it add 2-3 pounds of water mass tbh. It can supposedly help with brain function but I've never noticed a difference. I'd say to take it if you don't mind a little bit of fullness in your face
View quoted post on X