Twitxy Saved

Jonathan Panikoff

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@jpanikoff

Dir, Scowcroft ME Security Initiative @AtlanticCouncil; fmr @ODNI Dep NIO ME & Dir, ISG; ME, CFIUS, trade, US FP/natsec; Mets fan. Views my own; RT≠endorsement.
327 Following 2.5K Followers 105 Posts

Latest posts 5

Jonathan Panikoff Verified account @jpanikoff
Some early thoughts on what last night’s results mean for US policy toward the Middle East….
1) If President Trump‘s going to strike Iran intensely again, it’s going to happen during this lame-duck period as he’ll want to finish the entirety of US action before the new Congress takes over.
2) On the other-hand the likelihood the region faces a long-term low intensity conflict without a full resolution — a potential new normal the Gulf has already accepted — probably increases. The U.S. leaves, the Gulf states make their own own accommodations, and Israel faces a challenge of having to decide how to manage the challenge of Iran’s ballistic missile and nuclear capabilities potentially without nearly as much U.S. support.
3) Longer-term the result reinforces the already mounting bipartisan likelihood that most aid to Israel is likely to end in the way we know it, even as joint production is possible. But….
4) An underestimated is that a consequence of that is it is also likely to seriously endanger aid to Jordan and Egypt as well.
5) The election results are probably good news for the Israeli opposition including Eisenkot but are not going to be determinative as to what happens next in Israel’s government formation. But they perhaps will be a final death knell to what has been a terrible Israeli foreign policy effort over the last decade, that its foreign policy can, and perhaps even should, be partisan.
6) Gulf states will have a tough balancing act. They’re likely to align with Democrats on not restarting the war but are at risk of being part of the corruption accusations with the administration that are about to come.
7) On the other-hand as farmers and ranchers and many in the U.S. have learned, the Gulf states and the Strait of Hormuz and the Red Sea are critical to their lives, as well, with prices of energy and petroleum-derived products, fertilizers and helium, commodities across the board, dependent on the global market place. Reinforcing once again that like it or not, the Middle East is in the middle of the world and cannot be geographically wished away.
8) Policymakers across the aisle should be careful not to throw out the baby with the bath water. The war in Iran has been an unnecessary, unmitigated disaster that has diminished U.S. leverage and influence in the region and vastly overestimated, again, the likelihood that that hitting the Iranian regime hard would lead to its collapse. But the U.S. does have vital interests in the region and cooperation, partnership, and engagement there is critical for U.S. national security, including economic security — as the war has proven, they are one in the same.
@AtlanticCouncil @ACMideast
1 replies 14 reposts 90 likes 48K views View on X
Jonathan Panikoff Verified account @jpanikoff
There's a debate raging among Middle East experts on how to think about the future of the region, with one prominent view being that it's splitting into two blocs. Today, the @AtlanticCouncil published my alternative hypothesis in a new piece, entitled: "The new Middle East is modular: what the two bloc thesis of the region misses". I welcome hearing your thoughts, as well!
atlanticcouncil.org/content-series… @ACMideast
www.atlanticcouncil.org The new Middle East is modular In the Middle East today, states are aligning issue by issue, not choosing sides. They cooperate in one area and compete in the next. This modular alignment is shaping the region, even as it manages...
5 replies 11 reposts 38 likes 8.1K views View on X
Jonathan Panikoff Verified account @jpanikoff
I’m so incredibly saddened to hear about @AzizAlghashian’s passing. He was a great analyst and wonderful friend. My deepest condolences to his family.
Hasan Almustafa Verified account @halmustafa Oct 18
Deeply saddened by the loss of my friend, Saudi political researcher @AzizAlghashian.

A genuinely kind and thoughtful person. I always valued our conversations and his calm, insightful views, grounded in facts and free from prejudice.

May Allah grant him the highest place in Paradise.
View quoted post on X