"Three years into a genocide, the BBC cannot report children being crushed by a sand bank without putting Hamas's name on the people who counted their bodies."
Western media: The "Hamas-run" files.View quoted post on X
We read 45,577 passages of British and American news to count how often they say "according to the Hamas-run health ministry", and the reality is that they barely used the phrase until Israel began its genocide in Gaza.
Before 7 October 2023, these outlets put a Hamas label on Gaza's health ministry in 49 of 828 citations, which is 6%. Since then they have done it in 8,568 of 18,370, which is 47%.
Hamas has governed Gaza since 2007, and the same ministry counted the dead in 2014, 2018 and 2021 without anyone feeling the need to mention it. The label only became routine once the death toll became the record of a genocide.
What the figures show:
- The BBC News channel labelled 7 of 168 citations before October 2023, and 2,836 of 4,246 since (67%).
- BBC News online has labelled 1,493 of 1,789 since (83%), and nine in ten BBC articles that cite the ministry carry the label at least once.
- ABC, CBS, NBC and PBS went from 0 of 32 between them to 662 of 969. MSNBC went from 0 of 102 to 214 of 715.
- Broadcasters have said it on air 4,722 times since October 2023.
- The same outlets cited Israel's health ministry 174 times and never once called it Likud-run, Netanyahu-run or government-run.
Notice the double standard. "Hamas-run" is lazy to begin with, because the Palestinian Authority's health minister in Ramallah oversees the ministry, supplies its equipment and pays the staff hired before 2007. But the bigger problem is that the data shows these outlets use it in bad faith:
- The label exists to make you doubt the number. On 25 October 2023 President Biden said: "I have no confidence in the number that the Palestinians are using." The next day the White House called the ministry "just a front for Hamas", and CNN told its staff to describe it as "Hamas-controlled" "whenever we are referring to casualty statistics".
- The media fell into line within a month. The BBC News channel went from labelling 189 of 667 citations in October 2023 (28%) to 354 of 502 in November (71%).
- The numbers they are casting doubt on hold up. In 2014 the ministry reported 2,310 dead and the UN verified 2,251, and a peer-reviewed study in The Lancet found that the ministry had missed about two deaths in every five.
- On the BBC News channel, the only people who say "Labour-run NHS" are Conservative politicians attacking Labour. No presenter or reporter talks about a British institution that way.
- The BBC puts Hamas's name on Gaza's rescue workers too, the crews who dig families out of bombed houses, in 374 of 507 citations. CNN did it in 1 of 61.
- We found 223 passages calling Gaza's police "Hamas police" or similar, and 129 of them were reports that Israeli forces had struck, killed, targeted or detained those officers.
What makes this worse is that several outlets have shown the label is unnecessary, by dropping it and carrying on reporting the same figures:
- CNN labelled 146 of 200 citations in December 2023. In 2026 it has labelled 0 of 41.
- The Guardian went from 90 of 227 at the end of 2023 to 3 of 222 in the second half of 2025.
- The New York Times and Reuters hardly ever used it: 5 of 141 and 2 of 90.
The BBC has carried on regardless, labelling 54 of 85 citations on BBC News online since July 2026. Last week it reported that a sand embankment had collapsed onto tents in Gaza after heavy rain, killing three children and a woman, "the Hamas-run health ministry says".
Three years into a genocide, the BBC cannot report children being crushed by a sand bank without putting Hamas's name on the people who counted their bodies.
A label that is reserved for Palestinians, became routine in the same week the White House attacked the ministry and is never applied to Israel only serves to cast doubt on the Palestinian dead, which is unacceptable from a public broadcaster.
Every outlet's count, on air and in print, is in the full editorial: newscord.org/editorials/ham…