Last week’s local government elections delivered a clear verdict - South Africans are finished with incompetence and corruption.
They have also signalled that diversity of parties and approaches must form part of the solution if we are to pull our metros and municipalities out of the hole.
The biggest gains went to ActionSA, the Democratic Alliance, the MKP and the SACP. The SACP’s low single digit result is humbling after years of alliance politics, yet it shows the party can sustain a modest independent presence.
One reading of the shifts is that voters, outside Cape Town, eThekwini and Buffalo City, have bought into the service delivery visions offered by ActionSA and the DA. In eThekwini the pattern points toward an MKP led arrangement. In Buffalo City voters appear willing to see the ANC continue in some form of co-governance. This is not pure arithmetic; it is an interpretation of where support moved and what voters seem to be asking for.
A second, purely numerical reading allows coalitions that seize power. That route leans heavily on arithmetic. It is the easy way out. It spares parties the deeper introspection their records require, keeps them temporarily in the power equation, and softens the pain of rejection by constituents who have become more colour blind in their pursuit of basic services. The easy way, as the saying goes, often leads straight back in.
Tshwane illustrates one outcome of this path: ActionSA gained from the collective work of a coalition ably led by Dr Nasiphi Moya.
Cape Town shows the longer term version of the same dynamic. In 2006 the DA, as the largest party, formed a multi-party coalition under Helen Zille. The next local government elections in 2011 delivered an outright DA majority, which the party has held and, for a period, expanded ever since.
Consistent leadership and delivery can convert coalition support into durable majorities.
Johannesburg shows the other side: service delivery failures have rightly landed on the door of the mayor, Dada Morero, damaging the ANC. In all these cases the party that leads the coalition receives the credit for progress or carries the blame for failure.
This is the strategic trap. Parties that aspire to lead metros and municipalities in the longer term must ask themselves a hard question: if they will not lead the coalition, is propping up a competitor the best use of their seats?
The quick route to irrelevance is to lend weight to a government run by the party they ultimately hope to displace. The harder, and right, choice is to sit on the opposition benches. Sitting in opposition also helps citizens: it creates real accountability, keeps pressure on those in power to deliver, and gives voters a credible alternative when the next election arrives. It allows parties to build the credibility and record that future majorities require.
The hard thing to do and the right thing to do are usually the same thing. Voters have shown they will reward delivery and punish its absence.
Parties that treat this election as an invitation to short term arithmetic rather than long term accountability risk missing the deeper message. #ProudlySA
They have also signalled that diversity of parties and approaches must form part of the solution if we are to pull our metros and municipalities out of the hole.
The biggest gains went to ActionSA, the Democratic Alliance, the MKP and the SACP. The SACP’s low single digit result is humbling after years of alliance politics, yet it shows the party can sustain a modest independent presence.
One reading of the shifts is that voters, outside Cape Town, eThekwini and Buffalo City, have bought into the service delivery visions offered by ActionSA and the DA. In eThekwini the pattern points toward an MKP led arrangement. In Buffalo City voters appear willing to see the ANC continue in some form of co-governance. This is not pure arithmetic; it is an interpretation of where support moved and what voters seem to be asking for.
A second, purely numerical reading allows coalitions that seize power. That route leans heavily on arithmetic. It is the easy way out. It spares parties the deeper introspection their records require, keeps them temporarily in the power equation, and softens the pain of rejection by constituents who have become more colour blind in their pursuit of basic services. The easy way, as the saying goes, often leads straight back in.
Tshwane illustrates one outcome of this path: ActionSA gained from the collective work of a coalition ably led by Dr Nasiphi Moya.
Cape Town shows the longer term version of the same dynamic. In 2006 the DA, as the largest party, formed a multi-party coalition under Helen Zille. The next local government elections in 2011 delivered an outright DA majority, which the party has held and, for a period, expanded ever since.
Consistent leadership and delivery can convert coalition support into durable majorities.
Johannesburg shows the other side: service delivery failures have rightly landed on the door of the mayor, Dada Morero, damaging the ANC. In all these cases the party that leads the coalition receives the credit for progress or carries the blame for failure.
This is the strategic trap. Parties that aspire to lead metros and municipalities in the longer term must ask themselves a hard question: if they will not lead the coalition, is propping up a competitor the best use of their seats?
The quick route to irrelevance is to lend weight to a government run by the party they ultimately hope to displace. The harder, and right, choice is to sit on the opposition benches. Sitting in opposition also helps citizens: it creates real accountability, keeps pressure on those in power to deliver, and gives voters a credible alternative when the next election arrives. It allows parties to build the credibility and record that future majorities require.
The hard thing to do and the right thing to do are usually the same thing. Voters have shown they will reward delivery and punish its absence.
Parties that treat this election as an invitation to short term arithmetic rather than long term accountability risk missing the deeper message. #ProudlySA