Twitxy Saved

Museum Ghost

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@museumghostart

museum ghost. sometimes corporeal. friend of the artist. museumghost.eth by @jokawaharalino
museumghost.art Joined August 2025
314 Following 844 Followers 655 Posts

Latest posts 5

Museum Ghost Verified account @museumghostart
This is the part I was trying to get at all weekend. The stumbling IS PART of the learning curve, no model can equate one’s experience, which is often why pieces with a conceptual or lived component are so impactful.

“Ask me, I’m here to chat” is exactly what I meant by a generous elder.
James Merrill @toThePixel 1d
Making art you can't vibe code. ™️ You might be able to prompt your way into a frankenstein version of my art, but you were never in my shoes making it. You won't learn the lessons I did, stumbling, while creating it. If you that wisdom, ask me, not AI. I'm here to chat.
View quoted post on X
Museum Ghost Verified account @museumghostart
Thank you for this! We have spoken before, in a space I did under another name, so I know you mean it when you talk about craft.

It’s a very useful reply, and the Louvre rules do hold a lot of ground in it… but I read said rules as a form of support.
orkhan Verified account @Orkhan 3d
A Louvre copy and an LLM remake of @kimasendorf Monogrid are different acts. Here is some 101 art study ;)

A museum copyist gets only the surface. They rebuild the painting with their own eye and hand, and the rebuilding is the study. Van Gogh copied Millet from black and white prints and had to choose every colour himself.

The Louvre has rules for copies. The canvas must be one fifth smaller or larger than the original. No signature. Staff inspect the copy before it leaves the building. A study is never allowed to stand in for the work.

In generative art the work is the system. @museumghostart says so: "Originality lives in the system: the rules, the restraint, the sensibility behind them." If the system goes into an LLM and a version comes out, the original part is what was copied.

The same thread says a painted copy cost months and the labour was the lesson. Fine. Take the labour away and you still have the copy, with no lesson attached. So "studying" was the wrong word. tuukzs says he is not a coder. Then what did he study? If he studied it, he can explain one function or one variable.

Credit and not selling do not change what the piece is. Credit says whose work it was. It does not make a remake a study. The test is what went into the LLM and what came out. tuukzs has not said what he gave the model. If he believes it was a study, he should share the session history so we can all learn from it.

Readable code is not a gift. Kim open-sourced pixel sorting years ago, and that was his choice. Monogrid he minted as 1/1s. My artworks are on-chain and anyone can read them. That is for permanence. It gives nobody the right to remake them. Looking at a work and building your own is one thing. Feeding it to a photocopy machine is another.

To the artists who appeared overnight with Midjourney and an LLM: the model is a tool. If you can't make anything without it, you haven't studied yet. Take a drawing class, read the history, learn a real coding language, learn real software. Then come back to the LLM.

🎤
View quoted post on X
2 replies 2 reposts 18 likes 1.3K views View on X