Twitxy Saved

Nick Caputo

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@nickacaputo

AI, governance, law, etc. Assistant Professor @johnshopkins School of Government and Policy (SGP); Law & AI @aigioxford
nicholascaputo.com Joined August 2016
973 Following 1K Followers 125 Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Nick Caputo Verified account @nickacaputo
First substantive post from Model Constitutions is now out!

In it, I pick a fight and argue that the AI Constitutions are Real Constitutions.

Lots of people think that calling these things "constitutions" gives them more credit than they deserve.

But these documents are constitutional. They govern AIs and people, constitute artificial entities, and might be at the foundation of a new political order. They're also functionally constitutions, in that they use natural language, hierarchies of rules and principals, and interpretive methods to shape the behavior of intelligent beings.

Being constitutions does not necessarily make them legitimate tools of public governance. We need more public input and better understanding of how they work. But thinking of them as constitutions does help us see where we can do better.

Link below!
4 replies 5 reposts 50 likes 2.5K views View on X
Nick Caputo Verified account @nickacaputo
Incredible stuff here about agents interacting with social systems. No one (including the AI companies themselves apparently) is ready for the flood that’s coming
Jason Koebler @jason_koebler 1d
New: A man and his Muse AI agent sued Meta after Meta banned his Facebook account for using Muse

One of the weirdest phone calls I've ever had in my life and a sign of the world we're living in. A case study about the imminent breakdown of society

404media.co/a-man-and-his-…
View quoted post on X
Nick Caputo Verified account @nickacaputo
New version of the Turing Test where the subject has to tell if they're talking to a specific real person who they know or an AI pretending to be that person
Jack Verified account @tracewoodgrains Oct 19
tested Opus 5.5 on childhood_bench. from anonymized versions of my adolescent fiction, which contain no references to romance or religion, it predicts that I will leave Mormonism in my early twenties, come out as queer, and pursue an adult ADHD diagnosis
View quoted post on X
Nick Caputo Verified account @nickacaputo
New in Model Constitution! The original AI constitutions were designed to govern individual AIs. Now they have to govern entire organizations of them. Are AI constitutions still useful in the multiagent era?

Organizational misalignment can emerge through drift, miscoordination, and misunderstanding even when all the individuals within an organization are aligned. And AI swarms are going to start interacting with each other in high stakes scenarios outside of human oversight.

But human constitutionalism has tools for this. Constitutions govern complex agglomerations of people acting with significant independence through rules of delegation, authority, and enforcement.

I argue that multiagent AI requires a constitutional foundation for the four tools of governance that we use with human organizations: alignment, control, monitoring, and review. The constitutions need to allocate authority and create comprehensible structures within agent organizations, not just seek to align individuals. Claude’s Constitution, the Model Spec, and Microsoft’s draft Code of Conduct have made a start, but there is much more to do. And no single lab’s constitution can govern how its agents interact with everyone else’s.

Madison wrote in Federalist 51 that “If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary.” Perhaps, but a structure of government would likely still be. It is worth pursuing the traditional goal of alignment, building angels. But let’s also write constitutions for a world in which alignment is incomplete and controls are necessary, or in which even angels sometimes disagree.

Post here:
modelconstitution.com/p/constitution…
modelconstitution.com Constitutions for the multiagent era The four tools of (AI) governance