Twitxy Saved

Shailaja Chandra

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@over2shailaja

Public policy commentator. Author, Oped writer, public speaker.Vintage IAS!
Love telling stories!
RTs aren’t endorsements.
Delhi over2shailaja.wordpress.com Joined June 2010
618 Following 11K Followers 12K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Shailaja Chandra Verified account @over2shailaja
Odisha surprised us.
At 81 and 84 my husband and I travelled through Konark, Chilika, Puri and Dhauli with our son and grandson.
We found dolphins, temples that function like sundials, an unforgettable darshan at Jagannath — and beaches cleaner than many European coastlines I visited years ago.
Yet this remarkable state remains under-celebrated.
Some memories from the journey.
#Odisha #IncredibleIndia #TravelIndia

drive.google.com/file/d/15Lihkc…
108 replies 395 reposts 2.7K likes 114K views View on X
Shailaja Chandra Verified account @over2shailaja
“Madam, aaj mai nahi aungi. "
A short call or cryptic voice message—and that sinking feeling: unwashed utensils, unmade beds, a scattered home. Sometimes, no call at all. Anyone managing a home knows what it means to leave for work and return to that mess.

Yesterday, speaking at Udayan’s 25th anniversary at the India International Centre, I said organised home services deserve a place in discussions about women’s workforce participation which is very low in urban areas.
I speak from personal experience. I have used these services for cleaning, appliance repairs and even an occasional haircut when I couldn’t afford to spend two hours visiting a salon.
What do I like? A predetermined price, an agreed task, a booked time and a neutral way of giving feedback.
For twenty years, family visiting from abroad had asked: “Why must the whole house be turned upside down EVERY morning? Please stop it for the few days we are here.”
I didn’t listen! Wet floors, fans at full speed, rolled-up carpets, everyone retreating from room to room. Now I realise there is an alternative and thorough professional cleaning twice a week can make life considerably easier.
The professional workers arrive uniformed and conscious of their time. I welcome them with a smile, even a little banter to relieve a newcomers tension, take a 5 minute tour of the living spaces, show the supplies and sit back. I have rated thevmen and women generously because the work has always been good.
But as times move,why stop with house cleaning, appliance repair or home massages or grooming? These are needed but much more can be offered.
Next, we need an affordable, supervised concierge service for older people: forms, bills, appointments, groceries and those infuriating glitches in the television, phone or computer. Many also need help with medicine reminders, and running the washing machine. A trustworthy, reliable supervised service can bring enormous relief to senior citizens living alone.
Companies like Urban Company, Pronto and Snabbit have shown the possibilities.
India is changing. There is considerable scope to do more. Think big!
10 replies 11 reposts 72 likes 8K views View on X
Shailaja Chandra Verified account @over2shailaja
‘All-Powerful Man In District’: Allahabad HC Says Colonial Perception Of District Magistrate Must Be Shed share.google/JUfEzZVWhfB45p…

Respectfully, My Lords, the petitioner may have approached the wrong authority, but the observation that the District Magistrate's colonial image as an “all-powerful man” must be shed, risks being misunderstood.
People still approach DMs because they can deliver justice of another kind—not necessarily judicial justice, but administrative relief when it matters most.
During COVID, it was often the DM who ensured quarantine, vaccination and essential services were organised swiftly, cutting across social and economic barriers.
We should distinguish between colonial notions of authority and the continuing importance of a district officer empowered to act fairly, decisively and in the public interest. The latter is not a colonial vestige.
The judicial system in our country can hardly provide quick relief to common citizens. It is extremely slow, lawyers charge a big fat fee, and is quite opaque and inaccessible for getting quick relief for the common man.
lawbeat.in ‘All-Powerful Man In District’: Allahabad HC Says Colonial Perception Of District Magistrate Must... Allahabad High Court says citizens must shed the colonial-era perception of district magistrates as all-powerful authorities and approach civil courts for redressal of civil disputes, while hearing a...
11 replies 7 reposts 17 likes 2K views View on X
Shailaja Chandra Verified account @over2shailaja
@ChopraSanjeev 's articles on repeated extensions to senior IAS officers raise an issue far more troubling than the denial of opportunities to succeeding batches. It is the growing attraction of remaining indispensable, long after the normal age of retirement.
Power has its own intoxication. The authority to summon, decide, intervene and get things done; the prestige of being at the centre of government; the official residence, staff, security, social deference and the reflected importance enjoyed by one's family. After decades of such privilege, relinquishing it becomes harder than we care to admit. There is also the satisfaction of being seen by one's peers as someone whose services are considered indispensable—a public affirmation of one's exceptional standing. It secures a lifetime of social prestige.

The political executive has its own reasons for encouraging this dependence. Across governments, parties and states, trusted officers have always been valued for understanding political priorities, anticipating expectations and knowing how to get things done without elaborate instructions. Continuity and experience are legitimate considerations. But when familiarity becomes indispensability, the distinction between professional advice and political accommodation can become dangerously blurred.
What makes this arrangement particularly troubling is that it serves the interests of both sides while weakening the institution. Here's how:
The political executive retains someone whose responses are predictable. The officer retains authority, influence and privilege. Meanwhile, capable successors wait their turn, and the principle that institutions should outlast individuals is quietly undermined.
The Supreme Court's judgment in T.S.R. Subramanian and the Second Administrative Reforms Commission's recommendations sought to strengthen professional independence, security of tenure and institutional accountability. Yet neither is remembered or invoked, because the principles they embody are increasingly at odds with the civil servant's own understanding of achievement. Unfortunately, professional fulfilment has become synonymous with retaining the trappings of office, while proximity to political power has become the driving force.
My take:
The real measure of a civil servant's worth is not how long those in power wish to retain him, but what he accomplishes and what survives his departure.
Perhaps the greatest test of a public servant comes when the authority, privileges and deference disappear. Does the desire to serve remain just as strong? Or was remaining close to power itself the reward?Has anyone thought through the consequences?
@ChopraSanjeev 's two articles in ThePrint available here:
theprint.in/opinion/ias-ex…
theprint.in The real cost of IAS Extension Raj— batches that never get their turn The steel frame was built to bear weight. It was not built to be renewed one year at a time.
4 replies 9 reposts 23 likes 1.2K views View on X
Shailaja Chandra Verified account @over2shailaja
Abolishing pensions and lifelong privileges for legislators is one reform that could cost elections, provoke political turmoil and even bring down a government. No party would dare contemplate it, even prospectively. Yet it would probably win a 👍🏽 from 99.9% of voters! That is the tragedy: what voters would overwhelmingly welcome, their elected representatives would resist. Across party lines all legislators have a shared interest in preserving privileges, making reform politically difficult, even when it enjoys widespread public approval.
Harsh Goenka Verified account @hvgoenka Nov 9
Sri Lanka has abolished pensions for its parliamentarians. Public office is a responsibility, not a lifelong entitlement. Taxpayer money must serve the people, especially with pressing needs in healthcare and education.
Time to rethink political privileges in India?
View quoted post on X