Twitxy Saved

punkquidity

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@punkquidity

Who pays your yield, and can you get out? I break down DeFi products and the risks behind the numbers

Contributor @PythNetwork
DMs open for research & collab punkquidity.substack.com Joined July 2023
1.9K Following 7.4K Followers 453 Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

punkquidity Verified account @punkquidity
buybacks didn't save DeFi tokens that lost half their revenue

in my last post 12 of 16 tokens that pay holders still fell, so i widened the check to 26 DeFi tokens over the past year

for scale, $ETH fell 38% and $SOL fell 46% over the same year

what i found:

- 14 tokens lost half their revenue or more on DefiLlama (last 90 days vs the same 90 days a year ago), and all 14 fell, even $CAKE, $JUP and $SPK, which bought back tokens
- the median drop for these 14 was 44%, for the other 12 it was 11%
- the 5 tokens that went up ($HYPE, $RAY, $SKY, $UNI, $MORPHO) all kept more than half their revenue in that window, $RAY only after a launchpad wave in september
- each of the 5 also got something new over the past year, a fee switch with a 100M burn at @Uniswap, new markets and a fund treated as burned at @HyperliquidX, that launchpad wave at $RAY, cut emissions at $SKY and Apollo as a buyer at @Morpho
- keeping revenue wasn't enough on its own, $SYRUP and $LDO kept most of theirs and still fell 60% to 70%

a buyback is paid from revenue, so when revenue falls the buyback shrinks with it

the tokens that rose had both revenue that didn't halve and a fresh reason for someone to buy

$ENA has neither yet, fees are down 63%, team unlocks keep adding new tokens every month, while the fee switch needs $USDe at $7.5B and it's $5.0B now
punkquidity Verified account @punkquidity Nov 9
neither for $ENA holders because this loop pays them $0

they get no revenue until the fee switch arms, and that needs $USDe supply to average $7.5B

today it's $5.0B

to be fair, paying holders doesn't guarantee a token goes up

i took 18 DeFi tokens that earn real fees, from $HYPE and $UNI to $CRV and $PENDLE

16 of them pay holders through buybacks, burns or staking, and 12 of those 16 still fell over the past year

$MORPHO pays nothing and still went up

until the switch arms, holding $ENA is a bet on $USDe supply growing
View quoted post on X
12 replies 7 reposts 93 likes 8.9K views View on X
punkquidity Verified account @punkquidity
$sUSDS only makes sense if you need your money out any minute

this month @aave paid more on $USDC 64% of the time, 4.3% on average against a flat 3.8% at @SkyEcosystem

the catch is the exit: on oct 30, the day after the Binance hack, Aave's $2.7B pool had less than $11M free for about 5 hours, at one point just $40K

so for small money Aave wins most days, and the 0.5% you give up at Sky buys an exit that never closes
punkquidity Verified account @punkquidity
Sky's Spark covered a $104M exit from Coinbase's $BTC loans

Coinbase runs these loans through one @Morpho market on @base

yesterday a wallet that @ethena lists as $USDe backing pulled $104M of $USDC out of that market in two rounds, and both times @sparkfinance refilled most of the gap within 45 minutes

borrowers kept paying 5.2%, while without the refill the rate would have jumped to about 9%, unless another lender stepped in

Spark and @grovedotfinance, both funded by @SkyEcosystem, now supply 52% of the money in this market

so Sky is already the lender of last resort behind Coinbase's $BTC loans
punkquidity Verified account @punkquidity
$stUSDS now pays 14.75% with the exit still shut

a month ago the rate was 5.6%, and even now @SkyEcosystem's biggest $stUSDS holders can't withdraw a single dollar

what worries me is that the rate keeps climbing while withdrawals stay at $0

all of that money is lent to people who borrow against $SKY, so withdrawals open only when they repay

i don't expect that soon, because the biggest borrower, rune.eth, has repaid nothing in 6 months and owes $77M
punkquidity Verified account @punkquidity 4d
Sky's stUSDS pays 13% with $0 left to withdraw

all of @SkyEcosystem's stUSDS is lent out to people who borrow against staked $SKY, so the Sky app shows $0 available to withdraw

i checked the contract: even its biggest holders can't take out a single dollar right now

the last free dollars were withdrawn on the evening of nov 10. since then the rate has gone up every day, from 8% to 13%. the higher rate is meant to make borrowers repay and to bring in new deposits

the last time this happened, on oct 31, there was $0 free for most of the day. the rate went up to 10.7%, and by the evening people could withdraw again

this time it has been at $0 for 3.5 days

if you might need your $USDS soon, the wait matters more than the 13%
View quoted post on X
punkquidity Verified account @punkquidity
$sUSDe on Morpho is mostly used to borrow Ethena's own backing

98% of all $sUSDe collateral on @Morpho sits in one market

its only lender is a @SentoraHQ vault, 63% funded by a wallet that @ethena lists as $USDe backing

liquidations here depend on the $USDe market price, and the average loan already equals 87% of its $sUSDe collateral

a drop of about 5% in $USDe would liquidate the average loan, even with $USDe fully backed

so part of $USDe's backing depends on the price of $USDe itself