Twitxy Saved

A

@returningfromt2

Man Servant to Zeus
Sarcastic and offensive
People who drink Fosters are a danger to the public at large.

a@soapytitwank.com
Tarn Joined December 2020
2K Following 1.2K Followers 67K Posts

Latest posts 5

A @returningfromt2
Condensation connoisseur
Dr. Jeevun Sandher MP Verified account @JeevunSandher 1d
.@K_Niemietz has written an article disagreeing with my (and the government's) assertion that Net Zero will get bills down.

I think it's a fair critique so let me respond in full.

Most obvious point - Wind and solar are around *50% cheaper* than new natural gas from the latest auctions.

More broadly, his argument rests on 3 premises. Let me set out why I think all 3 are wrong.

1) "If renewables were cheap, companies would have built them." They have built out a *huge* amount of renewables in the UK. Something like 40% of our electricity is now cleaner, cheaper energy precisely because energy companies are building renewables.

2) "Renewables are subsidised so they can't be cheap". The fixed price under a CfD is not a one way subsidy. It is a guaranteed price that gives billpayers cash back when the wholesale price is high. We do this to ensure that generators with high upfront capital costs, but low marginal cost, get lower financing costs, which in turn brings prices down for consumers. The earlier renewables were more expensive than the ones we are building now because technology is getting better. So today's wind and solar are much cheaper *and their guaranteed price is much cheaper than natural gas*.

3) "If renewables are cheap, why aren't bills lower?" Renewables are making bills cheaper, but we are still stuck on the natural gas escalator. Gas sets the electricity price 60% of the time. Now that is down from 90% (good news) but there is further to go. Wind and solar already saved us around £6bn in gas imports. Moving old renewables off of gas will also help when the international gas price spikes.
View quoted post on X