Twitxy Saved

Robert Goudie

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@rob_goudie

Joined September 2021
427 Following 374 Followers 1.3K Posts

Latest posts 5

Robert Goudie Verified account @rob_goudie
#LucyLetby logic:

* 3 December 2024: Cheshire Police confirmed that Letby had been interviewed under caution about further deaths and collapses at the Countess of Chester and Liverpool Women's Hospitals. Further charges were albeing discussed.

* 9 June 2025: Dr Dewi Evans told Nation Cymru that the case against Letby was "stronger now than it was when she was convicted".

* 2 July 2025: The CPS confirmed that police had submitted evidence concerning further allegations for a charging decision.

* 20 January 2026: The CPS announced that none of the 11 proposed new charges, involving nine babies, met the evidential test for prosecution.

* 5 August 2026: Following requests under the Victims' Right to Review scheme, a different CPS prosecutor independently reconsidered six proposed attempted-murder charges involving six babies. All six decisions not to prosecute were upheld.

So ... we have something of a logical conundrum.

In June 2025, Dr Evans was confidently declaring that the case against Letby had become stronger while Cheshire Police were preparing further allegations arising from a broader investigation.

Seven months later, not a single one of the Cheshire Police's eleven proposed new charges met the minimum evidential threshold for prosecution.

So how did the first set of charges pass scrutiny if the evidence in the second set was supposedly more robust yet never even made it into court?

But perhaps more critically, to what extent did the second investigation rely on exactly the same clinical interpretations, expert opinions and methods of attributing unexplained neonatal collapses to deliberate harm that had secured the original convictions?

Given the published criticisms of the International Panel of Experts around the original investigation, why did the second investigation fail so comprehensively at the charging stage?

Curiously, while the Thirlwall Inquiry report in September 2026 stated that it had endeavoured to "keep abreast of press reporting, documentaries and other programmes about the criminal case", there was no discussion of the implications of the CPS blanket rejection of the eleven additional allegations - or the outcome of the review that upheld all six challenged decisions.
8 replies 16 reposts 62 likes 1.5K views View on X
Robert Goudie Verified account @rob_goudie
Worth noting that the first time #LucyLetby received anything approaching the independent, named multidisciplinary expert panel the National Crime Agency had recommended before the investigations had even got under way was after Letby's convictions - when her defence assembled its own international panel.

The failure to convene the NCA-recommended panel during the original investigation may be one of the most consequential procedural failures in the entire case.

And it exposes a systemic blind spot that runs through much of the subsequent legal commentary.

Consider Thirlwall's Recommendation 10.

In her report of 15 September 2026, Lady Justice Thirlwall recommended that the Department of Health and Social Care consider establishing a panel of independent experts from all specialties.

These experts would conduct independent technical investigations into emerging concerns about patient harm and could subsequently give evidence in legal proceedings.

Remarkably similar to what the NCA had recommended nine years earlier.

On 26 May 2017, the NCA advised Cheshire Police to appoint a panel comprising:

- Forensic and neonatal pathologists
- A forensic toxicologist or clinical pharmacologist
- A specialist neonatal nurse
- A doctor experienced in neonatal-unit practice
- An obstetrician
- Experts in medical statistics

On 28 June 2017, the NCA reportedly followed up with names of potential experts.

These details were placed on the parliamentary record by David Davis MP on 26 March 2026, drawing on an investigation by former assistant chief constable Dr Steve Watts.

According to Watts, Cheshire Police disregarded that advice and built its medical investigation around Dr Dewi Evans, who had volunteered his services.

Evans subsequently faced severe judicial criticism in an unrelated case. Lord Justice Jackson described his report as "worthless" and criticised his failure to provide a balanced opinion.

Other prosecution experts were eventually involved, but that was not the independent multidisciplinary investigative panel recommended by the NCA.

So did the Thirlwall Inquiry examine why such an essential safeguard had not been followed?

Not a bat squeak.

Admittedly, Thirlwall's terms of reference did not extend to reviewing the conduct of the criminal investigation. That is precisely the problem.

An inquiry that accepted the convictions as its starting point has recommended for future investigations a safeguard whose reported omission from the original investigation it never even sought to examine.

And the CCRC?

Its chair, Vera Baird, has said the Commission will examine the Thirlwall report to assess whether it has any bearing on its review of Letby's convictions.

A reasonable enough undertaking.

But that leaves this far more fundamental question unanswered:

Who is going to examine why the independent multidisciplinary investigation recommended in 2017 was never undertaken before Letby was prosecuted?

And what might such an investigation have concluded?
Martyn Pitman @MartynPitman 6d
Throughout my 3 decade career in Obstetrics every unexpected / unexplained stillbirth, intrapartum death and neonatal death was subjected to detailed Obstetric, Midwifery and Neonatal investigation. Initially conducted internally through Risk and Clinical Governance multi-...
View quoted post on X
9 replies 32 reposts 91 likes 4.8K views View on X
Robert Goudie Verified account @rob_goudie
Excellent. A long-overdue professional statistical analysis of the #LucyLetby case is finally under way, initiated outside the legal system.

This is precisely the kind of scrutiny that should have informed the decision on whether to prosecute in the first place.

Quotes: "The fact an event might be rare does not imply that a rare cause must be responsible for it.

"Courts seem to be extremely poor at grasping this critical concept. This is evident when the court looked only at collapses when Lucy Letby was present while ignoring other “suspicious events” after it turns out Lucy was never there catastrophically fails to grasp this key principle. ...

"We believe the public interest behind our research goes far beyond the fate of one person, and our commitment to publishing our findings no matter the result reflects that belief."
Richard Gill @gill1109 Nov 7
lnkd.in/p/eezN7FE2 Announcing a statistical investigation of the spike in deaths and collapses at the Countess of Chester in 2015–2016 and the association with nurses' presence #lucyletby
View quoted post on X