Twitxy Saved

శాంతి పసుమర్తి-Santhi

@santhi_ps

Joined September 2010
220 Following 1.4K Followers 67K Posts

Latest posts 5

శాంతి పసుమర్తి-Santhi @santhi_ps
Creative departures have always been there. Not just in Manas but in many other Ramayanas. Swayamvar, Lakshman Rekha, Maya Sita and many more. Nowhere is Ravana shown fighting a just fight for his people or that Rakshasas were oppressed and suffering in Rasatala.
Rajiv Malhotra Verified account @RajivMessage 23h
Tulsi Ramayana also has many departures from Valmiki. This caused a stir among some at the time, but the community embraced it, and it became the new standard.
Same point for Sagar’s TV Ramayana - it differs from Valmiki a lot and on top of that is further differs from Tulsi.
I will post a table comparing various stages of the evolution of Ramayana.
View quoted post on X
శాంతి పసుమర్తి-Santhi @santhi_ps
True. but Ravana's backstory is from Uttarakanda. And twisted to show Rakshasas being suppressed etc.
Surajit Dasgupta Verified account @surajitdasgupta 5h
None of the versions or traditions of the Ramayana — Krittibas Ojha’s Ramayan, Tulsidas’s Ramcharitmanas, Kamba Ramayana or Ramavataram, Jain Ramayana, Buddhist Ramayana, Malay Ramayana, Persian Ramayana, etc — fabricated a backstory of Ravana to justify his evil.

The script of Namit Malhotra’s Ramayana seems to be driven by Dravidian politics, which sees Ravana as a wronged ‘Dravidian’ king. Wronged by an ‘Aryan’ king, Rama.

If it were only this film, the backstory could have been considered a coincidence. But it is not. Several films made in the south — the latest Ramayana is made in collaboration with Kannadiga star Yash, who is not only the lead actor who plays Ravana but also the movie’s co-producer — have been trying to subtly build this narrative. Not so long ago, we saw Kalki 2898 AD, which turns the Mahabharata on its head, with the characters of Karna and Ashwatthama given positive spins. Earlier, we saw two Telugu films, the two-part Akhanda, that misrepresented Aghoris.

In the mid-1900s, EV Ramasamy (Periyar) pioneered an interpretation of the Ramayana that framed Ravana as a noble, egalitarian Dravidian king defending his indigenous kingdom against an aggressive, expansionist “Aryan” or northern domination.

Jyotirao Phule and BR Ambedkar similarly re-examined ancient texts through the lens of caste oppression, viewing mainstream narratives as victories of upper-tier forces over native, indigenous rulers.

The Nitesh Tiwari-directed Ramayana’s official chief researcher and historical consultant is Dr Akhilesh Bodhisattva (Akhilesh Kumar Mishra). His literary work operates within a specific socio-political and ideological framework. His writings, such as his 2024 book Ayodhya Mein Kaalpurush, consistently deconstruct ancient epics through the modern lenses of power dynamics, gender and social hierarchy. This approach often mirrors themes found in subaltern, Bahujan and anti-caste discourses. There, you see an agenda.

It is astounding that an erudite scholar and researcher like Rajiv Malhotra ji fails to see the facts and the pattern.
View quoted post on X
శాంతి పసుమర్తి-Santhi @santhi_ps
The language swung from formal, semi-formal to tapori Hindi. All over the spectrum. And Urdu words to. I heard Rama saying the word ‘बदले’
Pinki Verified account @PinkiPragya 1d
Watching Ramayana and came across this scene where Ravi Dubey, playing Lakshman, says, “Ab toot gaya toh toot gaya” in a full-on tapori style. 😂

I was literally laughing, wondering if the makers learned absolutely nothing from Adipurush. Didn't they realise that such cringe dialogues and out-of-place delivery were among the reasons audiences made fun of the film?

It's Ramayana, not some modern-day street comedy!

I'm sure many of you must have noticed this too. Or am I the only one who found this dialogue and its delivery so out of place? 😂

#Ramayana
View quoted post on X
4 replies 1 reposts 29 likes 1.6K views View on X
శాంతి పసుమర్తి-Santhi @santhi_ps
And Rama who did his actions with firm conviction and was rooted in Dharma apologizes for Surpanakha episode. Now this is your own classic case of misinterpretation. I know what kids in USA are thinking. Just told them to read.
Rajiv Malhotra Verified account @RajivMessage 20h
Good vs Evil is an Abrahamic religions concept in which God vs Devil are fighting and one must side with God, not Devil. There is no such concept in Vedic metaphysics. We have Dharma vs Adharma and these terms are NON-TRANSLATABLES into Abrahamic framework. For details read my book “Sanskrit Non-Translatables”. 🙏
View quoted post on X
0 replies 5 reposts 20 likes 553 views View on X
శాంతి పసుమర్తి-Santhi @santhi_ps
Ravana is shown fighting an Dharmic fight for his oppressed people. And Rama is in self-doubt about his destiny(bhagya). How about that?
Rajiv Malhotra Verified account @RajivMessage 20h
Good vs Evil is an Abrahamic religions concept in which God vs Devil are fighting and one must side with God, not Devil. There is no such concept in Vedic metaphysics. We have Dharma vs Adharma and these terms are NON-TRANSLATABLES into Abrahamic framework. For details read my book “Sanskrit Non-Translatables”. 🙏
View quoted post on X