Twitxy Saved

Steinn Sigurðsson

@steinly0

Astro Physicist. Scientific Director @arXiv
Planets, Stars, Black Holes & Stuff. Whole Universes, If Needed. Dynamics of Cats; To Say Nothing of The Dog.
catdynamics.blogspot.com Joined October 2010
952 Following 2.6K Followers 22K Posts

Latest posts 5

Steinn Sigurðsson @steinly0
Scott Armstrong Verified account @scottnarmstrong Nov 8
Let me restate my point like this.

If the community decides to treat all papers the same, then that's great! That would mean not rejecting papers with reports like "this is an amazing paper but the author used AI" -- which is really happening now.

I would be in favor of treating all papers the same and at this point I also assume all papers are heavily aided by the latest frontier models.

== HOWEVER ==

If we are going to have solemn declarations from Terry Tao and the Leiden declaration and so on about the super importance of declaring when you have used AI, then *EVERYBODY* has to do it and the AI disclosures must be *ACCURATE*.

What's not going to work is a system in which basically everyone uses AI but the people who are actually honest and transparent about their AI use are punished.

I'm not being hypothetical.

Unfortunately, this is the system we currently have!
View quoted post on X