Can someone explain to me why the top science and medical journals publish opinion pieces and editorial pieces at all?
I've never seen an opinion piece in the AER... When economists want to publish an opinion piece, they send it to the Times, WaPo, etc.
It's just not at all clear to me why Nature and NEJM need to publish these things. Aren't there a million other outlets that aren't scientific journals that could publish them where they would be more appropriate *and* more widely read?? Seems like there's a pretty easy solution here...
I've never seen an opinion piece in the AER... When economists want to publish an opinion piece, they send it to the Times, WaPo, etc.
It's just not at all clear to me why Nature and NEJM need to publish these things. Aren't there a million other outlets that aren't scientific journals that could publish them where they would be more appropriate *and* more widely read?? Seems like there's a pretty easy solution here...
James Watson and Francis Crick published their one-page paper “Molecular Structure of Nucleic Acids: A Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid” in Nature on 25 April 1953.View quoted post on X
That report elucidating the structure of DNA changed the entire world.
This is Nature's legacy and today it is publishing this toxic drivel in support of fraudulent academic Jason Arday.
I'm sorry to say but ... things are very bad and it does not bode well for the West.
This comes on the heels of The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) which published a piece by oncologist Kemi Doll that opens with the sentence:
“They are trying to kill us.”
She is not speaking metaphorically. That is literally her thesis. The “us” is Black academics. The “they” is some vague, ever-present wind of white supremacy and anti-blackness. The actual, documented record of Jason Arday’s career is treated as an inconvenient detail, or worse, as further proof of the conspiracy.
The NEJM is the medical journal that published Henry Jacob Bigelow’s 1846 account of ether anesthesia, the first public demonstration that surgery need not be agony. That article helped spread a technique that ended unimaginable suffering.
These premier scientific journals were once the opposite of propaganda. They played a sacred role in society as the mechanism by which claims were entered into the record so they could be tested, replicated, or discarded.
Now they publish emotional manifestos that treat documented academic fraud as a hate crime and skepticism as violence. Doll’s piece does not wrestle with the plagiarism, the fabricated quotes, the shoddy scholarship, the phantom visiting professorships, or the collapsing personal mythology. It simply declares the scrutiny itself as lethal radicalized violence.
That these writers believe these things is one thing but why are the journals debasing themselves by publishing them?
In James Baldwin’s ‘Beyond this House’ unfinished essay, he wrote that "the Negro does not want to be ‘understood’ or ‘liked’ by the White Man. He merely wants them to get out of his way."
So the editorial team of Nature and NEJM simply got out of the way, thereby continuing the public self-immolation of yet another institution we used to hold dear.