They caught it. They actually caught it…
And people are rooting against this???
And people are rooting against this???
@tomjohndesign
A great read mate! Really captured some of the sentiments i've been having lately. Here are my thoughts (sorry for the long form reply but I wanted to give your article some serious thought).View quoted post on X
Coming from a music background myself and to continue your analogy, some of the best conductors are often musicians and composers themselves.
Conducting also isn't just about coordinating - it involves an injection of oneself into the performance. They study the music, the instruments, the history of music etc and form their own interpretation of the music mixed with the composer's intent. This is akin to design taste (i know i hate that term too).
Even before AI tooling, I'd say that designers had similar thoughts when it came to strategy and PM crossover. As UX and UI roles started converging into PD, it meant that designers were also having to do more strategic thinking and end-to-end work. So a lot of time was also spent outside the canvas in decks coming up with narratives, visions etc. Our scope as designers increased, but the mission/outcome was the same.
Perhaps the design role is now converging again into a singular entity that requires the ability of a player, the intent of a composer, and now the skill of a conductor to wrap it all together for the audience in a way that communicates intent in the purist form available today. So it's just 'Design'.
Which brings us back to your OG question - what is design and what is a designer? After some time marinating on it, design for me is still about how you translate an idea into a purposeful form to solve a problem or to express a feeling. I think it's just easier to express that idea now and we have more control over the output.
What has changed though is how much time a designer spends in each part of the design process. Some people are more visual - so Canvas works better. Others more literal/verbal, so text/speech works better. I think with new tools the speed of them makes it easy to get through the process faster, which means signposting ideas/pivots/progress gets buried in a chat log. This is something we all probably need to get better at translating.
Where I draw the line for design though is maintaining an output. In music terms, this is the production team. They focus on technical and operational details so the conductor and musicians can focus on the music. This to me is the role of eng/dev. Maybe some designers want to do this too, but for this an abstraction too far and goes beyond 'design' and mixes masteries. There's only so much one can do before becoming a jack of all trades but master of none.
That was long - time for a walk😅
Announcement: CONDUCTOR IS BACKView quoted post on X
We’ve decided to continue development of Conductor!
Reports of our death have been greatly exaggerated (by us). Regularly scheduled updates will resume next week!
🫡🚂
View quoted post on X