Twitxy Saved

Aabhas Maldahiyar 🇮🇳

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@Aabhas24

Author- 5 books (Babur: The Quest for Hindustan, Babur: The Chessboard King,The Proclaimed Messiah of the Palestinian Cause) || Urban-Designer & Architect II
India aabhasmaldahiyar.in Joined January 2017
840 Following 159K Followers 168K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Aabhas Maldahiyar 🇮🇳 Verified account @Aabhas24
I am deeply humbled by the gracious gesture of the honourable Prime Minister of Israel, @netanyahu, in response to my book “Hitler: The Proclaimed Messiah of the Palestinian Cause.”

He writes: “It is throughly researched and compellingly presented, and it is suffused with your passion to do justice to Israel and the truth.”

Receiving a letter of appreciation directly from the Prime Minister, acknowledging receipt of the book, is an honour I will always cherish whole my life.

I extend my sincere gratitude to Ambassador @ReuvenAzar for ensuring that the copy reached the Prime Minister. His consistent support has meant a great deal.

I remain firmly committed to bringing forth the truth surrounding the cause of Israel; truths rooted in the historical realities of land and geopolitics around the Second World War, which today lie buried like crumpled paper beneath layers of selective amnesia. I genuinely believe that greater awareness of these facts will naturally create more allies for the cause of truth.

Israel and Bharat share an ancient civilisational bond, and as a Bhartiya, I hold this connection in the highest regard.

And above all, the most moving moment for me in the entire letter was the mention of “Bharat.”

@IsraeliPM @IsraelinIndia @BluOneInk @praveenBlu

Sharing a few buying links of book for people.
Amazon (hardcover) amzn.in/d/8EHw5d2
Kindle amzn.in/d/bU8noU3
@PadhegaIndia_ bit.ly/45426Xu
229 replies 1.1K reposts 3.7K likes 254K views View on X
Aabhas Maldahiyar 🇮🇳 Verified account @Aabhas24
In fact, @josyjosephkj should have known, particularly after writing this book, that Hindu Mahasabha leaders faced the wrath of the Government of Dominion India for advocating the cause of Akhand Bharat in the years immediately following Independence.

It is also worth examining the Hindu Mahasabha’s proposed Free Hindustan Constitution. Its stated framework was strikingly different from the usual caricature: no special concessions to minorities, but equally, no privileges or advantages for the majority. Equal citizenship, rather than communal appeasement or majoritarian privilege, was the principle it professed.

And let us get the chronology right. Sir Syed Ahmad Khan, the founder of the Aligarh movement, articulated the idea of Hindus and Muslims as distinct political communities decades before Savarkar was even born. The intellectual genealogy of the Two-Nation Theory cannot simply be rewritten to begin with Savarkar.

It is therefore unfortunate that someone writing on this subject appears to have missed the most elementary distinctions between who proposed what, when, and in what political context.

@iyuvrajpokharna is absolutely right on one crucial point: Savarkar envisaged Hindus and Muslims as two distinct nations, but did not advocate their territorial separation. His conception was of two nations inhabiting the same country. One may disagree with that political vision, but one cannot honestly conflate it with the demand for Partition.

And, for that matter, even Jawaharlal Nehru acknowledged the profound differences between Hindu and Islamic religious traditions, particularly their contrasting approaches to proselytisation and accommodation of other faiths.

History deserves better than convenient chronology, selective quotations and ideological shorthand. If we are going to debate the origins of the Two-Nation Theory, let us at least begin with the historical record.
Yuvraj Pokharna Verified account @iyuvrajpokharna 2d
Namaste @josyjosephkj

1. While Savarkar viewed Hindus and Muslims as separate cultural and religious nations, he fiercely opposed the geographical division of the subcontinent and advocated for a single, centralized, unitary Indian state ("Akhand Bharat")

2. Presidential Address to the Akhil Bharatiya Hindu Mahasabha (Ahmedabad, 1937): Often misquoted to claim Savarkar wanted partition, this speech actually laid out his vision for a single, unified political state. In it, Savarkar argued against splitting the country, stating: "Let the Indian State be purely Indian. Let it not recognise any invidious distinctions whatsoever in matters of franchise, public services, offices, or taxation on the grounds of religion or race."

3. In the second volume of his biography on Savarkar, @vikramsampath directly addresses and refutes the claim that Savarkar supported the partition of India. Sampath documents Savarkar's "Akhand Hindustan" campaigns during the 1940s, his opposition to the Cripps Mission and Cabinet Mission plans (which opened the door to provincial secession), and his vehement rejection of Jinnah's demand for Pakistan.

With utmost modesty, i request you to either consider these facts and make either amendments to your purportedly misleading and sensational claims or refute me. Either ways, the malicious campaign by a cohort should end.
View quoted post on X
3 replies 41 reposts 102 likes 4.1K views View on X
Aabhas Maldahiyar 🇮🇳 Verified account @Aabhas24
Dr Robert Lyman’s indignation would be considerably more convincing if it extended to the atrocities committed by the British Empire, rather than being selectively deployed to defend its historical reputation.

Let us begin with the facts.

Yes, Sikh historical tradition records that Bhai Dayala was boiled alive in a cauldron at Delhi in November 1675, during the persecution of Guru Tegh Bahadur and his companions under Aurangzeb. Bhai Mati Das was sawn in two; Bhai Sati Das was wrapped in cotton and burnt alive.

But where does Lyman’s argument go from here?

He suggests that boiling prisoners to death was recorded under the Mughals, never under the British, as though that somehow absolves British colonial rule of its own catalogue of barbarity.

Has he read the historical record of 1857?

On 13 June 1857, the British executed forty Indian soldiers at Peshawar by blowing them from the mouths of cannons. This was not an isolated incident. Hundreds of Indian rebels were subsequently subjected to this punishment. British troops also carried out mass hangings, summary executions and the destruction of villages.

Historian Jill C. Bender, in “The 1857 Indian Uprising and the British Empire” (Cambridge University Press, 2016), documents British soldiers forcing Muslims to have pork stuffed into their mouths before execution, compelling Hindus to lick bloodstains at Cawnpore, and blowing Indian prisoners apart with cannons.

Mark Condos, in his study of the Ajnala massacre, documents how Deputy Commissioner Frederick Cooper ordered 237 captured Indian soldiers executed without trial on 1 August 1857. Their bodies were dumped into a well.

And if these accounts are somehow insufficient, read the British officers themselves.

The British practice of execution by cannon was not even an invention of British jurisprudence. A 2024 study in the Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, titled ‘Blown from a Gun’, traces its earlier use in the Timurid (wrongly called Mughal) Empire and documents how the British adopted and extensively employed it in colonial India.

Notice the distinction: the British inherited a method of execution and turned it into an instrument of colonial terror.

Now, does acknowledging these British atrocities make the execution of Bhai Dayala any less horrific? Absolutely not.

Does acknowledging the brutality of Aurangzeb make the British Empire morally superior? Equally not.

And this is precisely where Lyman’s argument goes for a toss.

Historical scholarship is not a rehabilitation exercise for dead empires. We do not have to make the Timurids look better to expose the British. Nor do we have to make the British look better to condemn Aurangzeb.

An atrocity does not become less atrocious because another ruler committed one. A historical crime does not acquire moral legitimacy because a rival empire committed a different crime.

The British did not come to India as custodians of Indian civilisation. They came as conquerors, expanded their power through warfare, extracted wealth and maintained their dominion through coercion and violence.

And the Timurids were not benevolent custodians either. Their own record of conquest, religious persecution, executions and destruction must be examined honestly.

Our past is neither a British imperial morality play nor an exercise in rehabilitating the Timurid dynasty.

It is history. And history has no obligation to protect anyone’s political comfort, ancestral nostalgia or imperial reputation.

If historical accuracy is the standard, apply it universally. Otherwise, this is not a defence of history. It is selective outrage masquerading as scholarship.
Dr Robert Lyman 🇺🇦 Verified account @robert_lyman 2d
These videos are dangerous, inflammatory and entirely false.

The people producing these outrageous lies seek only to divide and destroy, using entirely manufactured stories of the past.

The boiling to death of prisoners is recorded to have occurred under the Moghuls, never by the British.

I wonder at the hatred of these attacks on our shared past as Britons and Indians. When people are prepared to make barefaced lies for the sake of a selfish political viewpoint, ethno-exceptionalism or plain racism, historical accuracy and our comprehension of the past are lost. It also compromises the security of the present, by turning people against each other.
View quoted post on X
4 replies 68 reposts 159 likes 6.4K views View on X
Aabhas Maldahiyar 🇮🇳 Verified account @Aabhas24
On this auspicious first day of Chhath Puja (Nahai Khae), I am delighted to announce my next book—a journey into the history, philosophy and civilisational story of one of Bharat’s most extraordinary festivals.

For me, Chhath is also childhood. I remember excitedly going to the ghats as one of my grandmothers—my father’s aunt—observed the fast. And, of course, waiting all year for thekua!

As I grew older, I began asking: where did this extraordinary tradition come from? Why do millions offer arghya to both the setting and rising Sun?

I searched for a book exploring Chhath beyond rituals—its history, philosophy, solar worship and its deep connection with Bharat and nature. I could not find the book I was looking for.

So I decided to write it.

Across the ancient world, great civilisations worshipped the Sun. Many ancient solar cults faded into history. Yet in Bharat, the relationship between humanity, nature and the Sun continues to live.

And Chhath is among its most beautiful expressions.

A journey that began with childhood memories—and perhaps thekua—is now becoming a book.

Chhath Puja ki hardik shubhkamnayein!