Twitxy Saved

Phil Gordon

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@PhilGordonDC

Sydney Stein, Jr., Scholar, Brookings. White House, NSC, and State Dept in Biden, Obama and Clinton admins. Author, Losing the Long Game.
700 Following 11K Followers 997 Posts

Latest posts 5

Phil Gordon Verified account @PhilGordonDC
This could not be more timely, and no better guides to the topic than @BuchananBen and @TantumSCollins.
Ben Buchanan Verified account @BuchananBen 6d
I remember the first time I walked into the Oval Office to brief President Biden. I'd just been appointed as the White House Special Advisor for AI. The President sat behind the Resolute desk and began with a single question: "What is the worst harm that AI could enable?"

I had no shortage of worries. We talked about the pace of technological progress — how, thanks to better chips and algorithms, what was cutting-edge that day would be commonplace within a couple of years. We talked about how high the ceiling on intelligence was, and about the dangers that AI would likely bring in areas like cybersecurity and bioweapons. We talked about how technology was fast and government was slow.

Then he asked about the benefits. He cared about ending cancer as much as anything in the world, and AI — managed well — offers more hope for that than anything else.

Most of all, we talked about what became the argument of the book my White House colleague @TantumSCollins and I have written: that democracies must lead in inventing this technology, turn that lead into a lasting advantage, and do it all without betraying their own values. Achieving all three at once will be a bitter struggle. Every choice pits security against liberty, speed against caution, power against principle.

Today THE BITTER STRUGGLE is out from Crown, in hardcover, ebook, and audio. It’s our account of what happened, what’s coming, and what’s at stake. We don’t pretend the answers are easy — in some ways we’re more worried than when we started. But these questions are too important to be debated only behind closed doors, including the door to the Oval Office. We hope you will join the debate.

penguinrandomhouse.com/books/821154/t…
View quoted post on X
1 replies 2 reposts 23 likes 1.7K views View on X
Phil Gordon Verified account @PhilGordonDC
Negotiations to end the war are welcome. But in the runup to these talks the Trump admin struck a deal to allow for the purchase of sanctioned diesel from Russia; waived the sanctions on Russian oil purchasers in the Lindsey Graham Act; berated Zelensky and called for new leadership in Ukraine; pressed Kyiv to halt attacks on Russian refineries; stalled the transfer of allied-funded Patriot interceptors to Ukraine; reportedly restricted Ukraine's access to satellite communications; and hosted and honored Putin envoy Dmitriev at the White House.

For a president so obsessed with leverage, you would think these would be steps that could be floated as possible outcomes of a negotiation rather than unilateral concessions made ahead of them.
Jared Kushner Verified account @jaredkushner Nov 9
President Trump is determined to bring an end to this horrible war, which has caused enormous loss of life, destruction, and suffering. We are working hard to find a negotiated solution that can deliver lasting peace and create the conditions for a sovereign, secure, and prosperous Ukraine within a more stable European security environment.

Before beginning the two days of trilateral talks with Ukraine and Russia in Abu Dhabi, @SEPeaceMissions and I will meet with our partners from Ukraine, the EU, NATO, Germany, France, the United Kingdom and Italy to continue the close consultation and coordination we have undertaken on European security and Ukraine’s postwar future over the past several weeks.

These will be the first trilateral talks since February. Building on our separate consultations with both sides, our objective is to bring Ukraine and Russia together to discuss directly their postwar security concerns, proposals, and potential solutions. We hope these discussions will identify areas of common ground, advance practical solutions, and build momentum toward the next phase of negotiations.

Ultimately, achieving a comprehensive and lasting settlement will also require direct engagement between Russia and our European partners on the broader security arrangements that affect them. We hope the discussions in Abu Dhabi will create the conditions for that engagement to begin in the near future, as part of a broader multilateral process.

Our work has focused on four interconnected priorities: ending the fighting, developing credible postwar security guarantees and arrangements that reduce the risk of renewed conflict, preparing a comprehensive economic and prosperity plan for Ukraine, and advancing humanitarian measures to alleviate suffering and address the human consequences of this war.

Together with Ukraine, the EU, and other European partners, we are working to address Ukraine’s substantial postwar fiscal and reconstruction needs, support critical infrastructure, attract private investment, and create the conditions for long-term economic growth and self-sufficiency.

We are also working with the parties on important humanitarian issues, including the return of prisoners and civilians, and practical measures to alleviate suffering and reduce the human cost of this conflict.

An important part of this process is encouraging all parties to begin thinking seriously about what comes after the war. By discussing postwar security, economic recovery, and the mechanisms needed to prevent future conflict, we hope to shift the focus from managing the war toward building the foundations for a durable peace.

The existing European security agreements and institutions provide an important foundation for this work. We want to build upon what has worked, identify where existing mechanisms have fallen short, and what practical improvements are needed to make them more effective in the future. Our discussions will focus on stronger consultation, reliable crisis communications, greater military transparency, and reciprocal measures to reduce escalation risks, while fully respecting the sovereignty and independent decision-making of every nation.

This is an extraordinarily difficult and complicated conflict. We recognize the difficult decisions ahead and are approaching these discussions with determination and realism. Our hope is to make meaningful progress, establish a practical pathway forward, and help create the conditions for a lasting peace.
View quoted post on X
2 replies 12 reposts 46 likes 3K views View on X
Phil Gordon Verified account @PhilGordonDC
It also means Liberman would rather abandon his insistence on Haredi military service (central not just to the opposition's campaign but to the principle of equality) than join a government that relied even passively on the Arab parties that represent 20% of Israel's citizens. And if restoring the broken relationship with US Democrats is among Israel's goals, treating those citizens' elected representatives as illegitimate doesn't seem like a good way to get there.
Mike Verified account @Doranimated Nov 6
The tweet below is a bombshell in Israeli politics. Avigdor Lieberman, leader of the Yisrael Beiteinu party, is warning that a short-lived minority government propped up by Arab parties (who would abstain rather than fully join) would collapse quickly and hand Benjamin Netanyahu an even larger majority next time.

Instead, he’s now open to a stable 61-seat majority coalition of opposition parties — presumably led by Gadi Eisenkot — plus the ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) parties. That would require softening the long-running fight over Haredi exemptions from Israel’s mandatory military draft, a hard-line issue he previously refused to compromise on.

His priority is ending the Netanyahu era and getting four years of stability, even if it means setting aside some of his old red lines.

This is a bombshell because Lieberman spent years campaigning on three clear red lines: no Netanyahu, no Arab parties, and no ultra-Orthodox. He repeatedly treated full Haredi conscription as non-negotiable and attacked rivals for any deal that preserved draft exemptions. By dropping the Haredi veto and signaling he will accept a softer draft arrangement, he is reversing his signature position and opening a realistic path to a majority government that had looked impossible.
View quoted post on X
7 replies 6 reposts 42 likes 5.8K views View on X
Phil Gordon Verified account @PhilGordonDC
Kushner's post is what you get when you put diplomatic negotiations in the hands of businessmen who have little experience with the issues, contempt for experts (and Europeans), potential financial incentives for deals with Russia, and a naive belief in the power of personal relationships with Russian leaders and officials.

The problem with the post is less its description of perfectly reasonable objectives for European security than the apparent unawareness that the agreements, institutions, and mechanisms proposed to achieve them have been in place for decades and that Russia has repeatedly violated them.

So long as Trump's diplomacy in Europe and Ukraine is based on the notion that Europe and Russia are equally responsible for the current state of affairs (or worse that Europe and Ukraine are more to blame than Moscow), it will only reinforce Russia's false hope that it can achieve its strategic and territorial ambitions in Europe.
Janis Kluge @jakluge Nov 7
Kushner's post on European security would be appropriate for the late Cold War period. It looks like he copy-pasted from the Helsinki Accords and the Charta of Paris. But we live in different times, and Kushner clearly has no idea how to address today's challenges.
View quoted post on X