Twitxy Saved

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@ProfVemsani

Distinguished Univ Professor@SSU multi-award Fulbright Honorary Prof@JNU 8Books Board:OAH,HAF,HUA,ICHRRF; Editor-in-Chief, Intnl Jrnl of Indic Rel;Pres,OAH,AAIS
shawnee.edu/academics/soci… Joined November 2013
24K Following 49K Followers 20K Posts

Latest posts 5

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. Verified account @ProfVemsani
#NoAryans #NoYamnaya replacement in India

Euro-centric scholarship projects European history onto India. Don’t fall for their half baked theories.

For example, the recent hypothesis about Yamnaya spread and replacement is more consequential to Europe than India.

1. Yamnaya and their Caucusus to European links and replacement of European population

Yamnaya male genome is dominated heavily by specific haplogroups, notably R1b

Studies published in Nature and Science revealed that Yamnaya-derived male lineages swept through Bronze Age Europe, replacing up to 90% of native Y-chromosome lines in places like Britain and nearly 100% in Iberia within a few centuries, even as local maternal (mtDNA) lines survived to a greater degree

2. Yamnaya related genetic heritage R1b is rare or absent in India

aplogroup R1b is generally very rare or largely absent across most of the Indian population, with average frequencies estimated to be around 1% to 5% in broad South Asian genetic surveys, and often near 0% in many specific regional or ethnic groups.
10 replies 61 reposts 177 likes 2K views View on X
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. Verified account @ProfVemsani
#NoAryans
1. Languages is not race. The linguistic theory is insufficient to explain Aryan race or their invasions or migrations. Nowhere was the term “Aryan” used as a race in the Vedas. It was just Arya that was found in the Vedas which signifies knowledge, refinement, or respect.

2. Lactose intolerance or tolerance is not linked to race or language. Indo-European language is not linked to lactose tolerance or intolerance. The European nations with Indo-European languages like Greece and Italy also have high lactose intolerance when compared to northern India.

3. And genetic history completely disproves the false Aryan invasion or migration theory.

#NoAryans
20 replies 70 reposts 195 likes 2.7K views View on X
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. Verified account @ProfVemsani
#NoAryans

What’s the date of the Vedas?

They decided it takes 200 years for something to go from oral record to literary record. This is based on their Bible experience. But they overrule the fact that the gap for oral to literary record might be different in the ancient world.

Do you think the evidence of Mittani inscription is enough to fix the Vedas at 1500 BCE based on the assumption that it takes 200 for oral record to transition into literary record? But the Vedas still remain oral so how does one reconcile with that? How can one fix that date of origin of something that refuses the rules of oral to literary transmission?