Twitxy Saved

The Charioteer

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@dacharioteer

tarkamuse.wordpress.com Joined October 2024
939 Following 165 Followers 2.8K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

The Charioteer Verified account @dacharioteer

Replying to @dub0081

Oh that! Good old classic "what about before British" comeback! Too old!

No worries! I am not here to insult, I am here to educate about ourselves. Let's jump right in:

* Did you know, when Greeks and Chinese called us India and Indhu, Britain did not even exist!

* Iranians called us Hindus too. (Geography= religion, just the same way, we now claim, Tamil region = Tamil religion!)

* Did you know, Britain did not exist before 1707? In ancient times, those islands were collectively called Britainnia, as we were called India.

* Was there a Germany before 1800s?

* I wouldn't go near America, Canada, Australia, but we know the land and people were always there.

* What was the religion of Iranian people, before Islam? Egypt? England? China? Greece? Turkey? See a pattern?
They all had their own names to mean a "path" . And they were all polytheistic too. We did too!

* In modern times, when countries formed, like minded principalities and feudal lands joined together to form countries. We too. Because all states in India are Dharmic states. We saw what happened when some parts did not think like us? Pak and B'Desh!

* Tamil Nadu (actually Chola Nadu, Pandya Nadu, Chera Nadu) was and is always in SE part of this landmass called India! Just the same ASIA was there (though it was not known as Asia).

* Yuan Tsang called us India Yin-du, Tian zhu in 7th century. And describes 5 parts of Tianzhu country he visited. (See graphic). Twmil Nadu was part of Nan-Tian zhu. Nan = South, Tian Zhu = India

Contd...
5 replies 3 reposts 5 likes 1.7K views View on X
The Charioteer Verified account @dacharioteer
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. Verified account @ProfVemsani 3d
There is no race called #Aryan and there are no invasions or migrations of such race. It’s all a myth. #NoAryans

Foundational Era

All aspects of Indian history trace to Metal Age Foundations.
Five thousand years ago India has given rise to the largest and widespread civilization- The Metal Age (Bronze-Chalco-Iron Age across India) are the Golden Age of India. It is the Foundational Age of India.
Those invasions are incorporated into Indian history at 1900 BCE and later adjusted to migrations between 1900-1600 BCE to disrupt continuity of Indian history from its Foundations to render Indians rootless nameless entities. For this theory to work there should have been a large societies civilization with large populations across the Steppes to spare eligible strong young men to go on scouting trips and then invasions or migrations. Like Trump said- “they are not sending their best people”. Even the most undesirable people should have been so civilized to found a civilized society after their invasion/migration. That doesn’t work.

Aryan myth

Aryan myth is the demon Raktabija of Indian history. It keeps raising its ugly head every time it’s slayed. New lame excuses to revise it are lactose intolerance and revival of language politics. Linguistics doesn’t justify race theories.
Anyways their Harvard guru accepted there is no evidence for Aryan invasion or migrations for that specific time period (1900-1600 BCE).

The problem with this artificial invasion or migrations theory is that non-historians always get too excited about using non-historical theories like linguistics or lactose- but they forget that history needs real evidence. Those theories are insufficient to prove historical events. There is no real historical evidence to prove arrival of any groups of people into India for 1900-1300 BCE. New people always bring their culture and leave evidence of it. where are the mass graves? Where is genetic evidence? Where is cultural evidence like pottery or new styles of lifestyle?
Continuity is the most important feature of Indian history. There is no big rise and fall or complete destruction of previous cultures like the West.
There is only continuity in Indian history no abrupt changes in genetics or culture which disproves any invasion or migrations from outside.
Truth triumphs!
View quoted post on X
The Charioteer Verified account @dacharioteer
Very good observation. For people who say, NT Ramarao did this, Ramanand Sagar did this fir precedence in artistic liberties, their audience were believers and people who learned Ramayana long before the movie from grandparents. Current generation questions Rama blindly and even calls him male chauvinist! Imagine such movies reaching broader audience who are not even exposed to our culture.

Dharma has nuances, modern laws are black and white. Modern movie makers try to rewrite history to fit modern narratives and in the process, lead to questioning our Gods and ethics, the very same they claim to portray in good light!
Any such movies need to be extra aware.

For those who say it's just a movie, enough damage has been done in TN in the last 70 years due to such distortions (in our case deliberately) that one group is now claiming Ravana as "Tamil king" and Rama as enemy !

I hope our censor board is more vigilant..
jinna naveen @jinna23 Nov 9
@dushyanthsridar Exactly.., atleast we all know the story and knows the truthfulness of those characters.. but since it a global movie, they are presenting a villain( a lustful & rapist) character as an idol & role model to some foreigners who don't know our ethihas and it's a shame...
View quoted post on X
The Charioteer Verified account @dacharioteer
Thank you for an excellent review👇 I have read several reviews, this touches the core of the issue. In summary, good movie, but lacks emotions and lacks devotion!

Apart from the actors' capabilities, their attitude towards Ramayana may also be a factor. If they walk in thinking they are acting in a Harry Potter movie, it will come out only that way - great, but not reflective of an Epic in India.

Music, I heard is a disappointment for others too. Dushyanth Sridhar points out a tune from Thyagaraja would have added the missing emotions!

As I watch many wsterners review Indian classical music in YouTube channels, I am learning about the richness of it. Personally, I feel Rahman's music is good, but someone like Ilayaraja maybe more invested emotionally in this film, being a believer of Rama!

Anyone can make a big budget movie these days and it may click also. Seems to me, they are capitalizing on India's greatest epic and revered and beloved God, without the reverence for him! Bottomline, get actors and director that actually believe in Rama, if you are going to make any movie about him!
Salvatore Babones @BabonesBhai Nov 9
Ramayana Part 1 - worth seeing once.
View quoted post on X