Twitxy Saved

Colin Gorrie

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@colingorrie

English is weirder than you think. Linguistics PhD. I read Old English for fun. Etymology, history, and the stories behind your words. Dead Language Society.
DeadLanguageSociety.com Joined February 2011
964 Following 24K Followers 5.9K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Colin Gorrie Verified account @colingorrie
English spelling is a cruel joke

Why does ‘gh’ stay silent in “daughter” but sound like an ‘f’ in “laughter”?

The thing is, English spelling is actually 100% logical — for the Middle Ages

Here’s how the 'gh' sound disappeared from English, and left chaos in its wake…🧵
309 replies 1.8K reposts 9.8K likes 1.5M views View on X
Colin Gorrie Verified account @colingorrie
A green man rides into King Arthur’s court. Green skin, green clothes, green horse.

He offers a game: any knight may swing his axe if he’ll accept a return blow in a year. Gawain takes the deal.

The head comes off… then the body picks it up and rides away.

That's the opening of "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight," written in the 14th century by a poet whose name we’ve lost.

The poem survives in a single manuscript that nearly burned in the Cotton Library fire of 1731. Like Beowulf, we nearly lost it entirely.

One of the joys of the poem is how it plays with language.

For example, when characters are at court, the language turns French: "plesaunce" 'pleasure,' "prys" 'excellence,' "ioye" 'joy.'

In some of these lines, every content word is French, with English supplying only the grammatical glue.

But when Gawain rides out through frozen wilderness, the poet switches to a Norse-inflected English:

- "felle" 'mountain' comes from Old Norse "fell/fjall"
- "dryʒe" 'patient' comes from Old Norse "drjúgr"

Here's what that wilderness ride looks like in the original:

Sumwhyle wyth wormez he werrez and with wolves als,
Sumwhile wyth wodwos þat woned in þe knarrez,
Boþe wyth bullez and berez, and borez oþerquyle,
And etaynez þat hym anelede of þe heʒe felle.
7 replies 19 reposts 222 likes 16K views View on X
Colin Gorrie Verified account @colingorrie
Linguists tend to talk about “Middle English” like it was one thing.

But Middle English was the most diverse period in the history of the language. If you only know “The Canterbury Tales,” you've only seen one kind of Middle English.

The anonymous poet of “Sir Gawain and the Green Knight” was a near-contemporary of Chaucer, but he wrote in a dialect so different from London English that Londoners like Chaucer would likely have struggled with it.

His vocabulary is four times as Norse as Chaucer’s. His verse combines rhyme with alliteration, merging the old Germanic ways with the newest French fashions. It’s a glimpse at an English that might have been.

It helps that it’s a great story too.
7 replies 51 reposts 250 likes 8.5K views View on X
Colin Gorrie Verified account @colingorrie
The surnames "Menzies" and "Mackenzie" were never meant to be pronounced with a 'z.'

The original spellings used the medieval yetter yogh, which looked like this: ȝ

Yogh once represented a 'y' sound in both English and Scots. So the name "Mackenȝie" was actually pronounced like "Mackenyie."

The 'ȝ' got replaced with a 'z' because the two letters looked similar, and 'z' was easier to print.

But the names were still pronounced with a 'y' sound by those in the know.

... not everyone was in the know.

When others encountered these spellings with 'z,' they did what seemed like the sensible thing: they pronounced them with a 'z' sound.

Hence the modern pronunciation of Mackenzie: with a 'z' sound.

The case of "Menȝies" is a bit more complicated.

Traditionally, it's pronounced like "Mingus."

It likely came from a Norman French name Mesnières, which ended up sounding like "Menyers" in Scots, hence the use of yogh: Menȝies.

Eventually, the "ny" sound in Menȝies became an "ng," which isn't far away in the mouth.

The pronunciation of "Menzies" as "Mingus" is still heard, but it's competing with the version said with a 'z.'

The language changed — albeit in a small way — simply because printers didn't have a letter.