Pinned post
Proponents of the Liberation Day tariffs can’t have it both ways.
A tariff that shuts off imports raises no revenue from them. A tariff that keeps raising large revenue has not shut off the imports. Americans are still buying the goods and paying the tax.
Yet both outcomes are treated as proof of success: falling imports mean the policy is working, and big revenue numbers mean the policy is working. Those can’t both be true at once. The more completely one claim holds, the less the other can.
A tariff that shuts off imports raises no revenue from them. A tariff that keeps raising large revenue has not shut off the imports. Americans are still buying the goods and paying the tax.
Yet both outcomes are treated as proof of success: falling imports mean the policy is working, and big revenue numbers mean the policy is working. Those can’t both be true at once. The more completely one claim holds, the less the other can.