Probably best to wait
x.com/Jason/status/2…
x.com/Jason/status/2…
View quoted post on X
@elieseid
View quoted post on X
One of the most important things to know about this AI cycle is that no one knows what they're talking and even very smart and plugged in people are continually reversing their opinions and then re-reversing them three months later.View quoted post on X
The ancient Greeks were often right: character is destiny. Hubris is one’s undoing.View quoted post on X
The warning signs in Graham Platner were there in plain sight. Many chose not to see them. Others extended him a presumption of grace they would never have given to their ideological enemies.
This is a moment not for schadenfreude, however tempting, but for self-reflection.
Today’s cover: George Soros and son Alex have funneled staggering $103M into midterms so far, on track to shatter spending record trib.al/vfu5pMkView quoted post on X
At only minute 4 you can see how @PeterBeinart has no idea what Palestinians or Arab society is.View quoted post on X
Beinart is a good man. He wants every government to grant every citizen equal rights and representation. This is the essence of the Thought of Enlightenment and democratic government.
Where Peter is totally wrong is that any government can grant equal rights to its citizens only, the ones who subscribe to such form of representative government, pledge allegiance to the state and pay taxes.
No government can grant non-citizens such rights, and especially not to non-citizens who think the very existence of this government must come to an end and be replaced by a different one.
There is not a single Palestinian who wants to pledge allegiance to the government of Israel. How can Israel then extend these Palestinians any rights that it extends to its own citizens? Now there are Arab citizens of Israel who are granted equal rights, but who are not allowed to organize politically along ethno-national lines. If they're ever allowed to, their political platform might be to replace the Jewish state with an Arab or Muslim one. This is why the Israeli constitution identifies them as minorities: Citizens with equal rights but whose collective identity cannot shape public space or life.
I'm a naturalized American citizen. A prerequisite to naturalization was for me to pledge allegiance to the republic. If America engages in war against any of my ancestral homelands -- Iraq or Lebanon -- I'll take the side of America, without even blinking. If any other naturalized American thinks otherwise, then they are not citizens, or at least they are treasonous citizens or a fifth column.
Peter confuses the equal rights for every citizen with equal rights for every human. Modern States can't operate this way, which defies the concept of the nation-state and social contract (constitution).
Israelis and Palestinians have two national projects in conflict over the same piece of land. Israel tried sharing, but Palestinians insisted on the "right of return" of Palestinians, not to their Palestine-to-be, but to Israel. This is proof that Palestinian peace is not that much of peace. It's a way of winning in negotiations what they could not win through violence: Annihilate Israel and replace it with Palestine. Given the Palestinian posture, Israelis are reciprocating. The current situation between them is the famous Middle Eastern maxim: "Either kill or get killed." One side will finish off the other and keep the whole land. The two billion Muslims are trying to shame the world to take the side of the Muslims against the Jews. As a Muslim born Arab, I think the Arabs have 21 sovereign governments and have no need for an extra failing state. It is in Arab interest to cede the land to Israel in order to maintain diversity in the Middle East, especially that such a successful state like Israel can be an asset to Arabs and their future in knowledge economy.
Until Beinart understands this very basic concept of the state, he'll keep projecting an American understanding of civil rights into two ethnic groups in conflict, neither of which is interested in his alien American ideas that do not apply to them. And rightly so. The majority of Palestinians want all of the land to become Palestine. This is what "From the River to the Sea, Palestine whatever..." The Israelis reciprocate: Greater Israel, which means Israel within the Mandate Palestine borders, not the "from the Euphrates to the Nile" nonsense.
Beinart is a good man, but he's too naive and alien to a conflict that he knows very little about, even if he's a Jew.
youtu.be/NMIndwkzMdo?si…