Pinned post
Guy Rowland
@guyrowlanduk
Writes words and makes sounds of various kinds. Not usually at the same time, but it has happened. Writing repped by @EchoLakeEnt
155 Following 1.7K Followers 6.6K Posts
Latest posts 5
During Lucy Letby's trial, her barrister asked about suspicious incidents investigated where she was absent.
The prosecution responded that there was no relevant material to disclose.
But the earlier police records show they found 11 of them.
All vanished into thin air.
The prosecution responded that there was no relevant material to disclose.
But the earlier police records show they found 11 of them.
All vanished into thin air.
My latest blog article, Lucy Letby: Dewi Evans and the "Doctored" Roster Chart.View quoted post on X
Dewi Evans, the lead police and prosecution medical expert in the Letby case, has boasted how easy it was for him to diagnose inflicted harm. And yet, leaked documents show he appears to have changed his diagnosis in relation to 30 of 49 clinical events, often because he diagnosed inflicted harm when Letby was not on duty. This is the "drawing around the arrow" that might prove at the Court of Appeal that the roster chart misled jurors in a material way.
mephitis.co/post/the-lucy-…
#letby #lucyletby
Scratch 1mm beneath the surface of any part of the Lucy Letby case, you find an NHS unit in crisis.
I have a relative in hospital right now. They're getting good care - in the week. At the weekend, the place is empty.
Caretakers managing decline.
Great from @GuerrillaCarl 👇
I have a relative in hospital right now. They're getting good care - in the week. At the weekend, the place is empty.
Caretakers managing decline.
Great from @GuerrillaCarl 👇
When we tell our story to people who work in hospitals, they ask what day she was born. We say Saturday and they roll their eyes. They already know.View quoted post on X
This is about what a weekend means on a maternity ward, and why families are the last to find out. x.com/i/article/2121…
You can get a free 7 day trial to listen to this extraordinary podcast.
Both hosts (inc Former Metropolitan Police Assistant Commissioner and former Head of UK Counter Terror Policing Neil Basu) clearly see huge problems with the safety of Lucy Letby's conviction.
Both hosts (inc Former Metropolitan Police Assistant Commissioner and former Head of UK Counter Terror Policing Neil Basu) clearly see huge problems with the safety of Lucy Letby's conviction.
Christopher Morris, author of Reasonable Doubt, believes the Lucy Letby case will be referred back to the Court of Appeal, citing multiple grounds of fresh evidence and dozens of expert reports submitted to the CCRC.View quoted post on X
Could the case be far from over?
Join Crime Agents Plus
ABSO-BLOODY-LUTELY THIS 👇
Worth noting that the first time #LucyLetby received anything approaching the independent, named multidisciplinary expert panel the National Crime Agency had recommended before the investigations had even got under way was after Letby's convictions - when her defence assembled its own international panel.View quoted post on X
The failure to convene the NCA-recommended panel during the original investigation may be one of the most consequential procedural failures in the entire case.
And it exposes a systemic blind spot that runs through much of the subsequent legal commentary.
Consider Thirlwall's Recommendation 10.
In her report of 15 September 2026, Lady Justice Thirlwall recommended that the Department of Health and Social Care consider establishing a panel of independent experts from all specialties.
These experts would conduct independent technical investigations into emerging concerns about patient harm and could subsequently give evidence in legal proceedings.
Remarkably similar to what the NCA had recommended nine years earlier.
On 26 May 2017, the NCA advised Cheshire Police to appoint a panel comprising:
- Forensic and neonatal pathologists
- A forensic toxicologist or clinical pharmacologist
- A specialist neonatal nurse
- A doctor experienced in neonatal-unit practice
- An obstetrician
- Experts in medical statistics
On 28 June 2017, the NCA reportedly followed up with names of potential experts.
These details were placed on the parliamentary record by David Davis MP on 26 March 2026, drawing on an investigation by former assistant chief constable Dr Steve Watts.
According to Watts, Cheshire Police disregarded that advice and built its medical investigation around Dr Dewi Evans, who had volunteered his services.
Evans subsequently faced severe judicial criticism in an unrelated case. Lord Justice Jackson described his report as "worthless" and criticised his failure to provide a balanced opinion.
Other prosecution experts were eventually involved, but that was not the independent multidisciplinary investigative panel recommended by the NCA.
So did the Thirlwall Inquiry examine why such an essential safeguard had not been followed?
Not a bat squeak.
Admittedly, Thirlwall's terms of reference did not extend to reviewing the conduct of the criminal investigation. That is precisely the problem.
An inquiry that accepted the convictions as its starting point has recommended for future investigations a safeguard whose reported omission from the original investigation it never even sought to examine.
And the CCRC?
Its chair, Vera Baird, has said the Commission will examine the Thirlwall report to assess whether it has any bearing on its review of Letby's convictions.
A reasonable enough undertaking.
But that leaves this far more fundamental question unanswered:
Who is going to examine why the independent multidisciplinary investigation recommended in 2017 was never undertaken before Letby was prosecuted?
And what might such an investigation have concluded?