Twitxy Saved

Jenn Gustetic 🚀💪🏻

Verified account IFP

@jenngustetic

Accelerating breakthrough research through metascience and R&D policy at @IFP. Tribes: @nasa @van_alen @SciPolNetwork @whostp44 @hks_digital @UF @TPPMIT
Washington DC jenngustetic.me Joined August 2009
3.9K Following 5.1K Followers 15K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Jenn Gustetic 🚀💪🏻 Verified account @jenngustetic
100% agree with Adam on this.

The nation's science portfolio should include a small allocation to focused, time-bound research organizations to complement established institutions like universities. The two play different roles and enable different kinds of value creation.

It's useful to think about it the same way as we construct investment portfolios that hold a small set-aside for venture as well as long-duration assets. That's a standard approach in financial portfolio construction and we should be clear that it’s also true for how the federal government should think about allocation.

The point is not to over-invest or concentrate in one type of performer. That means we also should not over-concentrate on new institution types, especially while they are an experiment.

We have 40 years of precedent for this. The SBIR/STTR program is funded at 3.65% of the extramural R&D budget and it has seeded thousands of small businesses creating new innovative products from research. Most of these companies don't survive in the long term and that's a feature not a bug. The turnover that happens through IPOs and mergers and acquisitions, as well as winding down companies, drives creative destruction and cycles of new ideas and talent.

FRO investments, other new institution shapes, and direct awards to individuals are analogous: they complement the permanent research base and create room for experimentation that's hard to do in existing institutional structures. But they in no way should replace it wholesale — just as SBIR shouldn’t replace industry R&D and angel/VC investments shouldn’t replace public markets.

Federal R&D obviously isn't a financial market. But allocation logic analogies are instructive: diversify across time horizons and risk, size new experiments modestly, and let turnover be a generative engine.

And this is critical: You can't diversify your way out of an underfunded, understaffed portfolio.

Universities, national labs, and industry are the core of that portfolio — experiments complement them, not replace them. To get the real benefits out of portfolio diversification, public R&D funding should grow, award flow needs to resume, and science agencies need to be staffed with adequate career staff.
Adam Marblestone Verified account @AdamMarblestone Jul 24
At
@Convergent_FROs
we’ve helped pioneer some of these approaches. We believe in them. That means we’re also clear-eyed that metascience innovations are potentially game-changing additions to America’s scientific core — not a replacement for it.
View quoted post on X
0 replies 3 reposts 11 likes 4.9K views View on X
Jenn Gustetic 🚀💪🏻 Verified account @jenngustetic
Nolan was one of the original innovators that broadly engaged the public to conduct meaningful science. @CoCoRaHS’s rain gauges helped to improve @NOAA weather models with in-situ volunteer measurements. It was an honor to get one of their gauges installed in the @ObamaWhiteHouse vegetable garden years ago and to host him as a guest at the White House Science Fair in 2015. Thank you for your kindness, ingenuity and infectious energy for science Nolan. Ad astra.
CoCoRaHS @CoCoRaHS 5d
It is with great sadness that we announce the passing of our colleague, mentor, and friend, Nolan J. Doesken. Nolan was the assistant state climatologist for 30 years and state climatologist for 10 years, and he founded the CoCoRaHS network. More at cocorahs.org/Content.aspx?p…
View quoted post on X
Jenn Gustetic 🚀💪🏻 Verified account @jenngustetic
A new @IEEESpectrum piece by @lucaslaursen highlights the potential for NSF X-labs in the words of consortium partners, science policy advocates, and applicants from academia like @zpirtle, @SloanFoundation, etc.

""X-Labs lets us explore things that are bigger than we can do in a lab, or that we might have done in a mine, but they won’t let us use their concentrators because they cost so much”, says one university researcher. The costs of getting it right exceed a typical university grant and the cost of getting it wrong is more than any industry partner wants to risk."

Very much looking forward to the first batch of awardees being announced (hopefully soon!) so we can learn more about how these institutional types complement research done in our universities, companies and national labs.

spectrum.ieee.org/national-scien…
spectrum.ieee.org NSF's X-Labs Let Engineers Build Big Science Outside Universities “Consortium partners” aim to help scientists conduct high-risk research on aggressive timelines
Jenn Gustetic 🚀💪🏻 Verified account @jenngustetic
This 👉 “because scientific progress is a supreme achievement of human intelligence, it must not be confused with a privilege reserved for millionaires seeking immortality”
Pope Leo XIV Verified account @Pontifex Nov 14
Today, the promises of transhumanism and posthumanism are multiplying. These are ideological currents according to which, sooner or later, technology will eliminate all disease and pain, as well as aging and even death itself. Precisely because scientific progress is a supreme achievement of human intelligence, it must not be confused with a privilege reserved for millionaires seeking immortality, while entire peoples suffer from poverty and oppression. In the face of this mirage, which promotes the illusion of human beings perfected by cybernetics and biotechnology, Christian anthropology reminds us that a limitation is not a manufacturing defect, but rather the very condition of human grandeur. #ApostolicJourney #Peru #MagnificaHumanitas vatican.va/content/leo-xi…
View quoted post on X
Jenn Gustetic 🚀💪🏻 Verified account @jenngustetic
Finished reading the second macroscience Econ of Innovation lecture series this morning over ☕️. In particular, I really appreciate the way @ChadJonesEcon lays out the impact of weak links of economic growth potential related to automation/ AI.

Working on solutions now for the problems associated with the increased capability and share of AI on work—jobs, what we’re going to do, inequality and meaningful work, and existential risk—is incredibly important.

“On the one hand, there’s the positive feedback loop — automation gives you new ideas, which gives you more automation, which gives you more ideas. There’s a flywheel effect. But there are also weak links, which limit the effect of automation. Imagine you’ve got a chain with 20 links, and I make 10 of the links infinitely strong. That’s good, but your chain is still limited by the weak links. Those weak-link effects can be very important.

You get really good at some things, but you’re always constrained by your weak links, and that slows down the [growth] explosion.”

open.substack.com/pub/macroscien…
www.macroscience.org Chad Jones on Idea-Based Models of Economic Growth Economics of Ideas, Science, and Innovation Lecture 2.