Twitxy Saved

Jonathan T. Rothwell

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@jtrothwell

Principal Economist at @Gallup, posting mostly about markets and wellbeing. Catholic, father, husband. Forthcoming book: a.co/d/0hvdrlYE
Washington DC linkedin.com/in/jtrothwell Joined December 2010
712 Following 3.4K Followers 4.7K Posts

Latest posts 5

Jonathan T. Rothwell Verified account @jtrothwell
Pew's forecast of religious demographics over the next 50 years is quite striking.

N. American and Europe are expected to see huge declines in Christian population shares in favor of mostly non-religious and Muslim populations. They estimate that Christians will lose 100m in population from loss of faith, as many European and N American Christians adopt agnosticism or atheism.

Births in SS Africa will allow the Christian faith to grow, as the global distribution of Christians goes from 33% living in Europe and N America in 2020 to 17% in 2070. SS Africa are projected to comprise the majority (54%) of Christians in 2070, up from 31% in 2020.

They forecast that the Christians living in Europe or N America will comprise only 5% of the global population by 2070, down from 9% today. They will be outnumbered 7:1 by Muslims living in Africa, Asia, and the Middle East, up from is 3:1 in 2020.
Jonathan T. Rothwell Verified account @jtrothwell
Good news: Adolescent mental health has substantially improved since 2021, as shown by: 1) falling hospitalizations from intentional injury 2) lower rates of depression, sadness, and suicidal ideation.

Possible explanations should consider changes in the fundamental causes of youth mental health. The most fundamental is parenting, which includes the quality of the parent-child relationship. Every survey that asks children about both parenting and mental health, shows parenting is the dominant explanation by a huge margin.

Could parenting have changed? There are very few nationally representative surveys of parenting and none that track it over time with more than a single item.

There are proxy measures of parenting that are easier to track. Religious belief and participation are both positively correlated with parent-child relationships and positive aspects of parenting (warmth, rule-setting, moral cultivation, non-negligence, non-harshness). Religious belief and participation are also weakly and positively correlated with youth mental health.

The same high-quality governemnt survey (SAMSHA) that shows major depressive episodes among youth rising and then falling, shows youth religious belief and participation falling and then rising.

Social media use may have declined or may have become more responsible or limited. Many states passed laws restricting smartphone use in schools and other regulations about access to accounts and parental oversight. The YRBS has a crude measure of social media use, which shows no decrease from 2023 to 2025. I am unaware of any high-quality surveys that consistently track social media use among adolescents over a longer time period. Apparently, evidence from one online marketing panel (GWI) shows social media use declining since 2021, but there are reasons to be skeptical.

In any case, social media use has about the same correlation with youth mental health as youth religious participation in the SAMSHA data and other sources I've studied.

There are very good reasons to believe that the pandemic--or the response to it--exacerbated youth mental health problems. Sports participation, for example, fell to the lowest level observed on the YRBS in 2021 and recovered to exceed the historic average in 2025; this pattern is surely related to the pandemic restrictions against socializing and sports, and the elimination of those restrictions; still, teen mental health had been declining leading up to the pandemic, so it cannot be the only cause. I could not find evidence that teens are spending substantially more time with one another in 2025 compared to before the pandemic, but I am aware of only one reliable source for this (Monitoring the Future).

As I said in the IFS article that went out today, youth mental problems remain with us, and parents must be at the heart of any effort to develop resilient children.
3 replies 6 reposts 28 likes 1.8K views View on X
Jonathan T. Rothwell Verified account @jtrothwell
U.S. teens saw notable declines in self-reported sadness and suicidal ideation from 2021 to 2025.

Relative to 2021, they were also more likely in 2025 to:
1) play sports (49% to 58%)
2) do strength training (45% to 51%)
2) eat fruit >=twice/day (19% to 28%)
3) eat at least one vegetable/day (55% to 63%)
45 replies 198 reposts 1.4K likes 260K views View on X
Jonathan T. Rothwell Verified account @jtrothwell
Country-level summary data from a new international study on mental health shows a large negative correlation between mental health and GDP per capita (r = -0.52) (via World Bank data) and a large positive correlation with the religiosity of the population (r = 0.54) (via Gallup World Poll data)
Kai Ruggeri @kairuggeri Nov 3
Mental health has gotten worse around the world but having a good job, an education, and people around you are still the best chances of doing well.

Much more on our study, Global Mental WEALTH, with over 250 collaborators from 92 countries now at link.springer.com/article/10.100…
View quoted post on X