Twitxy Saved

Kevin Vallier

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@kvallier

Political philosopher. Wannabe political theologian, political economist, and AI researcher. Incurably affable. Author, All the Kingdoms of the World.
Bowling Green, OH shorturl.at/wxAY6 Joined November 2008
1.7K Following 7.6K Followers 18K Posts

Latest posts 5

Kevin Vallier Verified account @kvallier
💯
Francesco Maggi Verified account @Frances01896069 8h
I am a bit confused by the negative reactions to Alpöge’s statement. The news he brought us is that, effective this morning, we have a publicly available, Lean-certified route to the summit of one of mathematics’ Mount Everests: the Riemann Hypothesis.

Of course, having a formally verified route is not the same as understanding the terrain. We still have a ton of work to do: identify the essential ideas, simplify the argument, understand why it works, and discover what new mathematical connections it reveals.

But now we have a route to the summit! Anyone familiar with mathematical research knows that turning a proof into understanding can be an enormous research program in itself, potentially generating a trove of new developments and insights.

I understand the sadness of losing a great guiding problem, and the anxiety about AI changing the way mathematical research is done. But neither makes the existence of a proof bad news. And, of course, there is no guarantee that the conceptual insights will come easily.

What I find particularly encouraging is that Alpöge himself seems fully committed to the task of understanding and explaining the mathematics.

We are not witnessing the end of a mathematical adventure. We may be witnessing the beginning of an even greater one.

How is this bad?
View quoted post on X
Kevin Vallier Verified account @kvallier
I'm not a Protestant, but some of the same ambiguities apply to Catholic and Orthodox positions. I think Catholic and Orthodox apologists often greatly overestimate the relative difficulty in justifying foundations for the interpretation of doctrine. We're not far better off than the Protestants.
Cameron Bertuzzi Verified account @CapturingChrist 8h
The more I think about Sola Scriptura, the more arbitrary it seems. Why just *written* words? Why this *set* of written words? It’s basically just cessationism applied to words on a page.

Arbitrary.
View quoted post on X
Kevin Vallier Verified account @kvallier
I think the Chinese Room argument works. I also think AI-operated machines can be conscious. Why? Because while minds aren’t programs, some programs may be able to *produce* minds in silicon-based brains by producing the electrical patterns found in carbon-based brains. Claude models won’t be conscious, but a robot with a Claude-part very well *might* be.
Phil Hoyeck Verified account @PAHoyeck 20h
John Searle explaining his Chinese Room thought experiment on a television program about artificial intelligence and the philosophy of mind.
View quoted post on X
Kevin Vallier Verified account @kvallier
Remarkable.
Kevin Hartnett Verified account @KSHartnett 10h
A statement from Alessandro Masullo about his proposed proof of RH. He didn't plan to post so soon and knows there is work to be done. "A human being has come up with these ideas. A human being has been assembling this math. I gave my word that I would see through through, all the way. This is me keeping it."
View quoted post on X
Kevin Vallier Verified account @kvallier
If it holds up, and with Trump, you never know, this could be incredible news: real negotiations with China to slow down the arms race. Combined with the Riemann announcement, it could be a good day for a human future.
Peter Wildeford🇺🇸🚀 Verified account @peterwildeford 14h
PRESIDENT TRUMP: "It's not artificial intelligence. It's not artificial, it's super. Problem is, it may be too super.

So, President Xi and I agreed that we're gonna do some joint guardrails, the two of us."
View quoted post on X