💯
I am a bit confused by the negative reactions to Alpöge’s statement. The news he brought us is that, effective this morning, we have a publicly available, Lean-certified route to the summit of one of mathematics’ Mount Everests: the Riemann Hypothesis.View quoted post on X
Of course, having a formally verified route is not the same as understanding the terrain. We still have a ton of work to do: identify the essential ideas, simplify the argument, understand why it works, and discover what new mathematical connections it reveals.
But now we have a route to the summit! Anyone familiar with mathematical research knows that turning a proof into understanding can be an enormous research program in itself, potentially generating a trove of new developments and insights.
I understand the sadness of losing a great guiding problem, and the anxiety about AI changing the way mathematical research is done. But neither makes the existence of a proof bad news. And, of course, there is no guarantee that the conceptual insights will come easily.
What I find particularly encouraging is that Alpöge himself seems fully committed to the task of understanding and explaining the mathematics.
We are not witnessing the end of a mathematical adventure. We may be witnessing the beginning of an even greater one.
How is this bad?