Twitxy Saved

Dr Svilena Dimitrova

@NeoDoc11

Consultant Neonatologist with a law degree. Interest in patient safety. CQC specialist adviser. Ex member of the Ockenden team. Bookworm. Opinions my own.
London, England Joined January 2019
567 Following 2.2K Followers 917 Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Dr Svilena Dimitrova @NeoDoc11
Lucy Letby is not innocent because her friends say she’s incapable of murder - she is innocent because the evidence shows she did not do anything wrong.

There is ZERO evidence that the babies were harmed deliberately. Their deteriorations and failed resuscitations were entirely explainable by pre-existing conditions and shockingly poor standards of care.

The prosecution’s case rested on the opinions of a single man with no relevant or recent neonatal experience - a self-promoting “expert” witness who claimed to have “only ever lost one case” and advanced bizarre implausible theories which brought him a generous income.

Crucial evidence of systemic failings and negligent care was ignored. Several clinicians involved have since been referred to the GMC, the police, and the coroner’s court for actions or failures that may constitute gross negligence manslaughter, contempt of court, and perjury. This is NEW evidence.

While experts may disagree on the specific causes of each deterioration or failed resuscitation, the public fail to understand how this is completely normal in complex medical cases (hence the concept of multiple differential diagnoses 🙄🙄) - there is clear unanimous agreement on two core aspects of the case - the standard of care these babies received was appalling. And no murders occurred.

The now-infamous “post-it note” evidence was misinterpreted and used manipulatively - a deeply flawed tactic that has been heavily precedented in other “caregiver” miscarriages of justice.

The “statistics” presented to the jury were laughably biased. The data was cherry picked to suit a narrative by doctors who could well have been struck off for incompetence or arrested for gross negligence manslaughter.

Police refused to investigate any cause of death other than murder.

Parents were misled and gaslit into believing their babies were deliberately harmed - long before the case even went to court.

Judge Goss allowed this miscarriage to unfold despite warnings. He allowed the doctors who were witnesses of fact to be treated as experts and thus to mark their own substandard work as excellent in front of a jury of lay people.

Media coverage was biased, sensationalist and instrumental in stoking a public witch hunt.

Whistleblowers stayed silent for fear of being scapegoated. Others were actively ignored by Cheshire police and LJ Thirlwall.

The legal profession oversaw a trial with no defence witnesses that was so one-sided it defied basic principles of logic, never mind justice.

This case is a national disgrace. It should shame the British legal system and the NHS and turn both into a global laughingstock.
65 replies 276 reposts 982 likes 67K views View on X
Dr Svilena Dimitrova @NeoDoc11
“Dr Bohin cannot rule out from the information available if the chest drains were tampered with or if the drains fell out accidentally. The frequency over such a short period of time in her view is suspicious. Further Dr Bohin thinks it unlikely that this baby spontaneously self extubated as she was well sedated.”

There is, however, a significant elephant in the room. In a unit where staff demonstrably lacked experience in inserting chest drains and where there were documented repeated difficulties in successfully intubating babies, the possibility of accidental drain and ET tube displacement arising from inadequate securing or handling cannot simply be overlooked. Indeed, the less experienced a doctor is at inserting and securing a drain, and the less experienced a nurse is at looking after intubated babies with chest drains, the greater the obvious potential for it to become repeatedly displaced accidentally.

The frequency may have been more concerning if the drains had been inserted and secured by highly experienced doctors, the babies had been nursed by highly experienced neonatal nurses, and there had been sufficient staffing to provide consistent one-to-one care. The evidence, however, indicates that these were not the circumstances at the Countess of Chester neonatal unit. The publicly documented evidence describes a unit in which staff had difficulties with procedures including chest-drain insertion and intubation. Even the parents’ own accounts describe staff Googling how to insert chest drains in their presence. Those circumstances should have clearly been considered when assessing whether repeated accidental displacement was unexpected and/or suspicious, or whether it was a foreseeable consequence of inadequate experience, technique or securing of the drains.

Given the documented deficiencies in experience, procedural competence and staffing within the unit, accidental displacement was in fact THE very obvious explanation.

@drphilhammond @PrivateEyeNews @PeterElston1 @MartynPitman @Michelehal7344 @Voice4theDead @guardiannews @guyrowlanduk @ClarkeMicah @sarahknapton @NadineDorries @nmcnews @bmj_latest @SpeechUnion @JusticeGap @gmcuk
Peter Elston Verified account @PeterElston1 Aug 16
I have been absent for a while from the writing scene but have just published this blog piece titled, "Letby Document Leak: Clear Evidence of Multiple CPS Disclosure Failings".

Documents leaked to me appear to indicate that information that would have helped Lucy Letby was withheld from her defence team by Mersey-Cheshire Crown Prosecution Service complex case officer Pascale Jones.

On a related matter, I want to say that I regret having been grumpy at times with Letby supporters over the last year or so. This has undermined my role as one of the key figures in the campaign to free Letby. If this has in any way hurt her campaign, I am truly sorry.

mephitis.co/post/letby-doc…

#LucyLetby
View quoted post on X
5 replies 36 reposts 102 likes 7.9K views View on X
Dr Svilena Dimitrova @NeoDoc11
Here is another example of what predictably happens when the water gets too hot - retirement.

This is how institutional witch hunts work. A public body puts someone senior - often someone approaching retirement - in a position of power. This normally means a very generous pay rise. They are then given the authority and institutional backing to pursue allegations and target someone on the organisation’s behalf.

And if someone actually persists in challenging them, and the water happens to get too hot? They retire.

On the rare occasions that the institution is forced to accept liability for what happened, it can distance itself from the individual who carried out the work. The person walks away with their topped up generous final salary linked pension and the institution can wash its hands of them.

It’s a remarkably convenient system.

And do you know who ultimately allows this to happen?

The general public. The taxpayer.

Because, ultimately, if we are happy for public institutions to put people in positions of enormous power, tolerate abuses of that power, provide enormous legal budgets to defend those decisions, and then allow the people involved to walk away into highly valuable pensions with no personal accountability, nothing is going to change.

Look at the NHS and policing. The taxpayer ends up paying for people who are either incompetent or purposefully abuse their power, or a combination of both, three times over:

First: the salaries of senior people who are incompetent and/or abuse their positions of power.

Second: the enormous legal costs incurred by institutions defending the actions of those people - often against individuals who are representing themselves or are poorly legally represented.

Third: the very generous pensions that are built on those senior leadership salaries.

The taxpayer can ends up funding the salary, funding the legal defence, and funding the retirement of those who carry out the institution’s dirty work. And if that is how the public is happy for its money to be spent, then there is not much incentive for institutions to change, so it continues on and on and on.

But perhaps the public should think about that the next time they complain about institutions. Because ultimately, the taxpayer has the power to demand accountability for how public money is being used. And if they don’t, then they shouldn’t be complaining when they are failed, repeatedly, by the very system they sponsor but do nothing about holding accountable.

@DavidDavisMP @drphilhammond @PrivateEyeNews @ClarkeMicah @MartynPitman @drcmday @cheshirepolice @ccrcupdate @CPSUK @DavidRoseUK @SpeechUnion @JusticeGap @TheBMA @BMA_Consultants @NHSEngland @amandaknox @AmandaFord45010 @PeterElston1 @Michelehal7344 @parthaskar @NadineDorries
According to his post on LinkedIn, Mark Roberts, the Chief Constable of Cheshire, will be retiring in November. linkedin.com/posts/mark-rob…
View quoted post on X
13 replies 20 reposts 81 likes 6.1K views View on X
Dr Svilena Dimitrova @NeoDoc11
So happy to read this Employment Tribunal judgment - with particular attention to point 7:

“Allegations against the Claimant were accepted and subjected to a prolonged nearly two-year investigation by the University even though they contained scant particularisation, and no evidence to support them. By contrast, a number of the Claimant’s detailed concerns or complaints were dismissed out of hand without a proper process.”

This is absolutely barn-door, classical institutional whistleblower witch-hunting - a pattern I have seen the clear evidence for over and over again supporting genuine whistleblowers in the NHS (please do remember that not everyone who claims to be a WB is one!).

That final judgment sentence could almost be the blueprint: vague and poorly evidenced allegations against the whistleblower are written down, inadequately investigated over a prolonged period and then, somehow, eventually “substantiated on the balance of probabilities” - despite there being little or no objective evidence that they ever happened, beyond the mutually reinforcing accounts of several members of the same witch-hunting gang, whose own conduct had itself been raised as a matter of concern but which, miraculously, nobody seems to remember they were supposed to investigate.

Meanwhile, the whistleblower’s own detailed, evidenced concerns - including concerns specifically raised about the conduct of individual members of that very same witch-hunting gang - are dismissed, minimised or simply never properly investigated; in some cases, they are not even mentioned. There seems to be an almost magical expectation that the documented history will somehow disappear if you can bully the whistleblower into submission by burying them under vexatious allegations they must defend themselves against, while simultaneously threatening their professional reputation and livelihood.

I genuinely no longer know whether the root cause of such behaviours is malice or stupidity. On the balance of probabilities, I suspect it exists on a spectrum of both, depending on the individuals involved.

I am currently dealing with a couple of NHS cases that follow this precise pattern. Looking forward to being able to tell you much more about them in due course - hopefully very publicly, including the names of the individuals responsible for the decisions and processes involved.

Well done to these brave whistleblowers for taking on a powerful establishment and seeing it through. We need more and more people willing to calling out poor behaviours. Nothing will get better until there is accountability.

P.S. As I’ve commented repeatedly, the truly remarkable thing about the Letby case is that the witch-hunt played out through the criminal justice system rather than through the more familiar NHS mechanisms - mechanisms that bear striking similarities to the pattern described in this case, and which are classical witch-hunting techniques that conform to the same pattern exposed by this fabulous guide published by the @HCSANews.

hcsa.com/wp-content/upl…

Ever since I reviewed the notes and records relating to what happened to Lucy Letby, I have started counselling the whistleblowers I am supporting that they can at least focus on being grateful that their Trust's retaliatory objective is “only” to get them sacked and destroy their professional reputations. Because it could be worse - you could end up in prison, with the key effectively thrown away, courtesy to our criminal justice system being just as dysfunctional as our internal trust procedures and regulatory bodies, for crimes which never happened.

@PrivateEyeNews @drphilhammond @ClarkeMicah @PeterElston1 @SpeechUnion @HCSANews @DavidDavisMP @MartynPitman @drcmday @TheBMA @DavidRoseUK @JusticeGap @Voice4theDead @Michelehal7344 @cheshirepolice @CPSUK @ccrcupdate @VeraBaird
Shocking ET Judgment against Cambridge University - serious failures of honesty, competence & integrity across HR, legal & senior leadership. A classic case of closing ranks to punish the whistleblower.

21percent.org/wp-content/upl…
View quoted post on X
1 replies 19 reposts 58 likes 5.7K views View on X
Dr Svilena Dimitrova @NeoDoc11
As I wake up to the news that Chief Constable of Cheshire police, Mark Roberts, has prematurely retired, I read his resignation speech with great curiosity and note he forgot to mention that he also played a role in publicly marking his own homework and awarding himself an A****** - describing his own force's Operation Hummingbird investigation into the non-existent crimes of Lucy Letby as both “impressive” and “exceptional.”

Picture attached, courtesy of @northerness (as the system won’t allow me to quote your post directly).

To be fair, the Lucy Letby investigation was impressive and exceptional.

It is genuinely impressive and exceptional that, in this day and age, one investigation could accommodate so much groupthink, so little critical thinking, so many cognitive errors, such failures to explore alternative explanations, such intimidation and/or marginalisation of witnesses who challenged the pre-decided narrative, such certain conclusions presented to vulnerable parents before proper investigation, such colossal failures to investigate potentially poor medical practice, and such biased and/or unqualified "experts" building a case, while simultaneously allowing those whose own practice warranted scrutiny to shout “burn the witch” at a vulnerable target - one whose conviction would rather magically make all those uncomfortable questions about their own deficiencies disappear in a convenient puff of smoke.

Overall, this amounted to a remarkably efficient modern-day reconstruction of a medieval witch-hunt - merely aided and abetted, on this occasion, by the criminal courts, rather than conducted through the NHS’s more customary venues for its witch-trials: internal proceedings or referrals to the GMC/NMC.

So on that point, I do agree with Mark Roberts - impressive and exceptional are the right words for it.

I wish him a long and fruitful retirement. And I sincerely hope his conscience doesn't choose some inconvenient moment to wake up and interfere with the enjoyment of what no doubt be a generous state-funded pension.

@drphilhammond @PrivateEyeNews @cheshirepolice @ClarkeMicah @PeterElston1 @sarahknapton @Michelehal7344 @Voice4theDead @Oversig58651516 @FelicityLa76731 @DavidDavisMP @DavidRoseUK @ccrcupdate @NHSEngland @guyrowlanduk @MartynPitman
Mark Roberts, Chief Constable of Cheshire Police, has retired. He said: "I had hoped to take the force through to 2028, but the decision has been made to take the force in a different direction." cheshire.police.uk/news/cheshire/…
View quoted post on X